Friday, May 08, 2015

dna exclusive: DoT awakens to cancer-causing cellphone towers

dna exclusive: DoT awakens to cancer-causing cellphone towers

Sunday, 7 April 2013 - 9:00am IST Updated: Sunday, 7 April 2013 - 12:36pm IST | Place: Mumbai | Agency: dna

Jury out on harm from wireless devices; experts preach caution

Jury out on harm from wireless devices; experts preach caution

Wireless Safety
It's not clear whether wireless devices are harmful for your health. But Health Canada has recommendations to reduce your radiofrequency risk. (AP Photo / Mark Lennihan)
Sheryl Ubelacker, The Canadian Press Published Tuesday, May 5, 2015 4:06PM EDT 
TORONTO -- Wireless devices like smartphones and tablets have certainly made staying in touch and plugging into the digital world easier and more convenient.
But the increasingly ubiquitous nature of the technology is also raising concerns about possible adverse health effects from exposure to the electromagnetic radiofrequency waves that these devices emit.
Worries about exposure to EM-RF fields were recently raised before the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health, which heard three days of submissions from international medical experts, advocacy groups and industry players.
The all-party committee will now prepare a report on those submissions, which will be tabled in the House of Commons in the coming weeks, said Liberal MP Hedy Fry, who introduced a motion asking the committee to study the potential harms from wireless emissions.
The report could make recommendations to Health Canada, including that the department reconsider exposure limits under regulations known as Safety Code 6 based on the "precautionary principle" -- or the idea that it's better to be safe than sorry.
In March, Health Canada tweaked Safety Code 6 guidelines following a review of international research by a Royal Society of Canada expert panel, which concluded that current exposure thresholds appear to be mostly adequate.
However, its April 2014 report said Health Canada should undertake more research to determine if there's a link between emissions and cases of cancer, and it also suggested children may need greater protection.
Some critics said the panel's report overlooked 140 studies that showed a possible link between EM-RF exposure and some types of cancer, as well as other health effects, including electromagnetic hypersensitivity.
"We're hoping that the committee sends a strong message to Health Canada that they did not follow proper international standards when they reviewed the evidence," said Frank Clegg, CEO of the non-profit group Canadians for Safe Technology (C4ST).
"The government has a responsibility now to let Canadians know that there's a high probability that there is harm if you don't use these devices properly," said Clegg, who supports MP Terence Young's private member's Bill C-648, which would require manufacturers to prominently display safety warnings on packaging of cellphones and other wireless devices.
"We're not saying don't use the technology. We're just saying use it safely."
International studies looking at possible adverse health effects related to cellphones, cell towers, WiFi and other equipment have come to mixed conclusions, said Paul Demers, who chaired the Royal Society panel.
"It remains a controversial area, but when various government agencies around the world have put together expert committees to evaluate this, they've always come down that the evidence isn't there yet," said Demers, director of the Occupational Cancer Research Centre at Cancer Care Ontario.
In 2011, the WHO's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) concluded that radiofrequency fields are "possibly" carcinogenic.
"But the evidence is still quite mixed," Demers said.
Some studies have suggested that cellphones may increase the risk for certain brain tumours -- primarily among the heaviest users -- while other research found no connection. Doctors have reported that a small number of women who carried cellphones in their bras had developed an unusual form of breast cancer, but there is no proof of cause and effect. Other researchers have tied emissions to possible infertility, based on studies that showed exposure-related effects on sperm.
"One piece that has always given us pause is that some of these positive studies have said that there is this very large increase in (brain tumour) risk from any cellphone use," said Demers.
"If that was the case, our brain tumour rates all over the world would be going up right now -- and they're not.
"If there's some kind of smaller effect, that still remains possible. It may be we simply haven't been using them long enough to have seen an effect yet ... often it takes decades for us to be able to see a pattern associated with an increased risk of cancer.
"So it is early days yet on that level to really see this and it's one reason that we've called for ongoing research in this area."
Epidemiologist Dr. Anthony Miller, a professor emeritus at the University of Toronto's Dalla Lana School of Public Health, has spent his decades-long career investigating the impact of nutrition, radiation and occupation on the development of various types of cancer.
In late 2011, Miller was asked by IARC to review the evidence assessed by its working group that led members to conclude that exposure to electromagnetic radiofrequency fields was a possible cause of cancer.
After reviewing the literature, he believes emissions are not only possibly cancer-causing, but "probably" cancer-causing. He said the federal government should adopt the precautionary principle and put stronger warnings on cellphones and other wireless devices to protect consumers.
"The general feeling that Health Canada seems to want to put out is that these are perfectly safe, there's no hazard," said Miller, who last month appeared before the Standing Committee on Health.
"And yet if we're at the beginning of a period of increasing exposure of a new possibly -- probably -- carcinogen, it could be some years before we get a major impact seen in the population," he said in an interview.
"But by then it will too late."
Bernard Lord, president and CEO of the Canadian Wireless Telecommunications Association, told the committee that worldwide research continues to support the conclusion that there's no demonstrated health risk associated with the use of wireless technology.
"When exposures remain below the safety limits set by science-based EMF exposure standards, including Health Canada's Safety Code 6, no adverse effects have been proven through credible scientific evidence," he said.
One expert calling for more rigorous research is Dr. Riina Bray, who is seeing more and more patients with what's been dubbed electromagnetic hypersensitivity, or EHS -- a cluster of symptoms that includes headache, fatigue, poor concentration, heart palpitations and digestive disturbances.
Bray, medical director of the Environmental Health Clinic at Women's College Hospital in Toronto, believes exposure to EM-RF fields is a likely cause of EHS, but proper research to prove a connection hasn't been done.
"I'm saying that it's so poorly studied and it's out of control," she said of the omnipresent technology, including WiFi.
Children are of particular concern because their smaller size and developing bodies and brains could make them more vulnerable to adverse health outcomes, said Bray, recommending that schools, homes and workplaces be hardwired to the digital world rather than connected by wave-emitting WiFi.
"We can't wait years from now to see if what we did was wrong," she said.
Here are some tips for reducing exposure to electromagnetic radiofrequency waves, based on the precautionary principle:
  •    Turn off cellphones or tablets when not needed, or turn on airline mode.
     
  •    Keep cellphones away from your head as much as possible. Use speakerphone mode or earbuds for phone calls rather than a Bluetooth headset. Don't carry your phone in your pocket or bra.
     
  •    Do not sleep with wireless devices near you.
     
  •    Keep cellphones and tablets away from small children.
     
  •    Do not place a wireless baby monitor by your child's bed. Use a wired monitor instead.
     
  •    Use hardwired Internet connections for computers in your home instead of using WiFi. Turn wireless router off at night, do not keep it in high-use or sleeping areas.
     
  •    Pregnant women should keep wireless devices away from the abdomen.
     
  •    Avoid cordless phones.

http://www.ctvnews.ca/health/jury-out-on-harm-from-wireless-devices-experts-preach-caution-1.2360073

Parliament of Canada H.E.S.A. committee minutes on wireless radiation, 23 April 2015

Parliament of Canada H.E.S.A. committee minutes on wireless radiation, 23 April 2015

 
These studies, we believe, reinforce the evidence that radio frequency fields are not just a possible human carcinogen but a probable human carcinogen, putting it in the category 2A. It would be impossible to ignore such a hazard in regulatory approaches.
 
English
 
 
French
 

Canadian Medical Association Journal reports Health Canada's wireless limits are "A Disaster to Public Health"


Canadian Medical Association Journal reports Health Canada's wireless limits are "A Disaster to Public Health"

OTTAWA, May 7, 2015 /CNW/ - The Canadian Medical Association Journal today published a scathing condemnation of Health Canada's safety guidelines for cell phones and Wifi.
The Journal (CMAJ) interviewed multiple international experts in radiation and cancer, who warn that the microwave levels allowed in Canadian classrooms, residences and workplaces are, "a disaster to public health."

One scientist said that given the overwhelming evidence that wireless radiation is harmful, Health Canada staff are either, "unwilling or not competent to make evaluation of the current literature."

The article points out that Canada's Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health recently completed three days of hearings on Canada's safety guidelines, and sent federal scientists back to the office to re-examine 140 recent studies that show wireless radiation emitted by cell phones and WiFi can cause harm.

One oncologist interviewed by the CMAJ said that Canada's safety guidelines for wireless radiation need to be "urgently revised" due to the obvious risk of cancer.

The CMAJ article revealed that James McNamee, who wrote Health Canada's safety code, has also co-authored academic papers with scientists who openly accept payments from the wireless industry.

"That Canada's wireless safety code is out of date and mired in conflict of interest is no longer a question it's a fact," said Frank Clegg, CEO of Canadians For Safe Technology (C4ST).

"We're hoping the Parliamentary Standing Committee will have strong recommendations to fix it," said Clegg.

SOURCE C4ST: Canadians For Safe Technology
For further information:
Interviews Frank Clegg, Contact: media@C4ST.org, Phone: 705-444-9662, Background: www.c4st.org/HESA2015

Press release from the Global Union Against Radiation Deployment from Space

Press release from the Global Union Against Radiation Deployment from Space


Excerpt:

Sent in by Sarah Benson for distribution:

Global Union Against Radiation Deployment from Space

For Immediate Release

Date: March 25, 2015

Who: Global Union Against Radiation Deployment from Space (GUARDS)

Contact: Ed Friedman, Maine USA, 207-666-3372 edfomb@comcast.net

Planned Global WiFi from Space Will Destroy Ozone Layer,

Worsen Climate Change, and Threaten Life on Earth

Five companies are gearing up to provide high-speed global WiFi coverage from space within the next three to four years. This would be an ecological and public health nightmare, according to a recently-formed international coalition: the Global Union Against Radiation Deployment from Space (GUARDS). 

According to GUARDS, the extensive satellite networks required will endanger the ozone layer and significantly contribute to climate change. Rocket exhaust contains ozone-destroying chlorine, water vapor (a greenhouse gas), and aluminum oxide particles, which seed stratospheric clouds. Complete ozone destruction is observed in the exhaust plumes of rockets.

The New York Times (May 14, 1991, p. 4) quoted Aleksandr Dunayev of the Russian Space Agency saying “About 300 launches of the space shuttle each year would be a catastrophe and the ozone layer would be completely destroyed.” 

SNIP

Read the post here.

Brain Tumor Rates Are Rising in the U.S. & other wireless radiation news

Brain Tumor Rates Are Rising in the U.S. & other wireless radiation news


Next week two major developments regarding wireless radiation and health will occur:
  • On Monday, May 11th, the embargo will be lifted on a Business Wire press release about an appeal to world leaders by EMF scientists to address the emerging public health risks due to the proliferation of electromagnetic fields (EMF) emitted by electrical and wireless devices. More information is forthcoming.

  •  On Tuesday, May 12th, the Berkeley (California) City Council will vote on a Cell Phone "Right to Know" Ordinance which would make Berkeley the only city in the nation to require cell phone dealers to provide new customers with safety information about wireless radiation. 

In the interim, you may find some of my posts on Electromagnetic Radiation Safety during the past month of interest:

Brain Tumor Rates Are Rising in the US: The Role of Cell Phone & Cordless Phone Use

The Incidence of Meningioma, a Non-Malignant Brain Tumor, is Increasing in the U.S.

Heavy Use of Cell Phones & Cordless Phones Increases Brain Tumor Risk


Berkeley Cell Phone "Right to Know" Ordinance


California Medical Association Calls for Stronger Wireless Communication Safety Standards
Welcome to EMR Safety - Overview, Recent News Stories, Radio Interviews & Presentations

Mobilize: A Film About Cell Phone Radiation

Tips to Reduce Your Exposure to Wireless Radiation

--

Joel M. Moskowitz, Ph.D., Director
Center for Family and Community Health
School of Public Health
University of California, Berkeley

Electromagnetic Radiation Safety

Website:               http://www.saferemr.com
Facebook:             http://www.facebook.com/SaferEMR
News Releases      http://pressroom.prlog.org/jmm716/
Twitter:                  @berkeleyprc

Thursday, May 07, 2015

“Scientists Decry Canada’s Outdated Wi-Fi Safety Rules”

Scientists decry Canada’s outdated Wi-Fi safety rules
Scientists and safety advocates say Health Canada new rules do not take into account many new studies on the safety of cellphones and other wireless devices.

Paul Christopher Webster, Toronto, Ont.
May 7, 2015

Federal parliamentarians concluded three hearings into Health Canada's safety regulations for cellphones and other wireless devices by asking for a detailed analysis of numerous recent cancer studies that indicate far tougher safety regulations may be warranted.
The studies in question were not acknowledged in the scientific review, Safety Code 6 (2015) — Rationale, which exclusively released to CMAJ by Health Canada. The Safety Code 6 guideline, which was released Mar. 13, states that no new biological information pertinent to safety guidelines has emerged since 2009. Further, it states that the large number of recent studies raising safety concerns "suffer from a lack of evidence of causality, biological plausibility and reproducibility and do not provide a credible foundation for making science-based recommendations."
This contention led scientists and safety advocates at the hearings before Parliament's Standing Committee on Health to mount a withering attack, saying that Health Canada's Rationale and Safety Code 6 are outdated, incomplete and invalid. 
As a result, at the conclusion of the hearings on Apr. 30, the Standing Committee on Health asked Health Canada to "provide detailed information in the form of a full scientific monograph" on its assessment of 140 studies identified as alarming by Canadians for Safe Technology, an Oakville, Ontario–based advocacy group. 
The group's CEO, Frank Clegg told the health committee on Apr. 23 that despite paying the Royal Society of Canada $100 000 to convene a panel to assess the safety of radiowave-emitting devices (a panel that was subsequently marred by conflict-of-interest allegations and the resignation of its chairman) "Health Canada has not invested the necessary time, nor had the balanced opinion of experts necessary to undertake a proper review."
After noting that health regulators failed to forestall public health disasters with tobacco, asbestos, bisphenol A, thalidomide, DDT and urea formaldehyde insulation, Clegg said "prudent avoidance" should be recommended with cellphones and Wi-Fi "until the science proves beyond reasonable doubt that there is no potential for harm. For the last three years science has published a new study every month that shows irreparable harm at levels below Safety Code 6."
Clegg told the health committee that China and Russia have guidelines 100 times safer than Health Canada's Safety Code 6. "Canada should be among progressive countries such as France, Belgium and Taiwan that have laws in place to protect children in the home and at school or daycare centres," Clegg says.
"A proper scientific evaluation would clearly show that Health Canada is not taking the appropriate action to safeguard the health of Canadians."
Clegg's comments echo those of Terence Young, the Conservative MP for Oakville, Ont. who has a record of successfully proposing and passing health safety legislation. In January, Young tabled a private member's bill that would require manufacturers to place clearly visible safety warnings on all cellphones, cordless phones and radio frequency–emitting devices such as Wi-Fi transmitters. 
In an intense confrontation at the health committee meeting, Young demanded that Health Canada explain its methodologies for rejecting evidence from a series of recently published studies by Swedish researcher Dr. Lennart Hardell. In his most recent study, Hardell concluded "that glioma and also acoustic neuroma are caused by RF-EMF emissions from wireless phones, and thus regarded as carcinogenic …indicating that current guidelines for exposure should be urgently revised" (Pathophysiology 2015;22:1-13).
James McNamee, chief, Health Effects and Assessments Division, at Health Canada's Healthy Environments and Consumer Safety Branch, who is the Rationale's principal author, responded to Young's inquiry. He said the department's evaluation principally relied on a scientific review completed in May 2011 by the World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), which concluded that cellphones and other wireless devices such as cordless phones and Wi-Fi transmitters are possibly — although not probably — carcinogenic.
"We're subject to the evidence base we have at this time," said McNamee, who coauthored two scientific reviews with scientists who have acknowledged accepting payments from industry and government in return for promoting industry and government safety assurances (J Toxicol Environ Health B 2009​12:2004-7; Int J Radiat Biol 2005 81:189-203).
McNamee's reliance on the studies included in the IARC's four-year-old review as still the most pertinent evidence available was subsequently called into question during the health committee hearings by one the IARC review's own authors.
Dr. Anthony Miller, a University of Toronto professor emeritus who served as scientific secretary for the IARC panel, says Hardell's new research "reinforces the evidence that radio frequency fields are not just a possible human carcinogen, but a probable human carcinogen." 
Hardell's studies, Miller told the committee members, "would be impossible to ignore in regulatory approaches to such a hazard" had Health Canada carefully considered them.
Hardell agrees. After reviewing the Rationale, Hardell described Health Canada's safety guidelines in an interview with CMAJ as "a disaster to public health" and based on a scientific analysis "unwilling or not competent to make evaluation of the current literature."
Miller says the Rationale overlooks numerous other important studies as well as Hardell's, including a recent study by Gaëlle Coureau, of Université Bordeaux Segalen, which concluded that it supports "previous findings concerning a possible association between heavy mobile phone use and brain tumours" (Occup Environ Med 2014;71:514–22).
After reviewing the Rationale, Coureau told CMAJ its analysis of the epidemiological literature did not warrant discussion.
Hardell and Coureau are not the only authors of recent studies raising concerns about cellphone safety who take issue with McNamee's Rationale and Safety Code 6. 
At McGill University in Montréal, Paul Héroux, author of a recent paper indicating extra-low-frequency magnetic fields alter cancer cells through metabolic restriction, describes the Rationale as a document that deliberately ignores all studies that call Safety Code 6into question (Electromagn Biol Med 2014;​33:264-75). "The soul of science is to revise health protection when evidence undermines previous thinking and this review fails to do that."
At Washington University in Seattle, Henry Lai, author of numerous studies indicating radiofrequency exposure appears to affect DNA damage and repair, described the Rationale to CMAJ as "simplistic and out-of-date" with "too much focus on dosimetry and theoretical calculations, at the expense of basic concepts of biology and health"
The Rationale, Lai adds "fails to take into account at least a couple of hundred papers published between 2009 and 2014 on the biological effects of radiofrequency radiation, such as changes in cellular and reproductive functions. Many of these studies show effects at exposure levels much lower than the [Safety Code 6] limits."
Although CMAJ was invited by Health Canada to interview McNamee before he testified to the committee, the invitation was withdrawn without explanation after he testified. In response to written questions submitted to McNamee by CMAJ, Health Canada emailed a statement on Apr. 30 explaining that "Departmental scientists considered all available peer-reviewed scientific studies when developing the exposure limits in the revised Safety Code 6."
Their review "employed a weight-of-evidence approach when evaluating possible health risks," the Department explained, while acknowledging it has elected not to publish McNamee's Rationale on its website devoted to Safety Code 6. "Health Canada's updated Safety Code 6 makes Canada's limits among the most stringent science-based limits in the world," it added.