Sunday, May 11, 2014

Pinto desestima la reclamación por responsabilidad patrimonial de un vecino por "daños" de dos estaciones de telefonía (Pinto dismisses the claim for liability of a neighbor "damage" two telephone stations)

Pinto desestima la reclamación por responsabilidad patrimonial de un vecino por "daños" de dos estaciones de telefonía

Ayuntamiento de Pinto
Foto: EUROPA PRESS
MADRID, 17 Feb. (EUROPA PRESS) -
   El Ayuntamiento de Pinto ha desestimado la reclamación, presentada en enero de 2013, de un vecino que pedía la responsabilidad patrimonial del Consistorio, por daños y perjuicios ocasionados por la instalación y funcionamiento de dos Estaciones de Base de telefonía móvil situadas en la azotea del edificio ubicado en la calle Joan Miró, 10.
   Según ha explicado el Gobierno local, en su reclamación este vecino solicitaba una indemnización de 136.189,98 euros y ha sido desestimada tras los informes técnicos dictados al respecto y en los que se señala que "el Estado español tiene competencia exclusiva para regular el Dominio público Radioeléctrico".
   "La Administración del Estado ha dictado el RD 1066/2001 de 28 de septiembre, por el que se aprueba el Reglamento que establece las condiciones de protección del dominio público radioeléctrico, restricciones a las emisiones radioeléctricas y medidas de protección sanitaria, con una base científica que la sustenta", destacan.
   Este Real Decreto establece que la Inspección y Certificación de las Instalaciones radioeléctricas pertenece a los Servicios Técnicos del Ministerio correspondiente.
   Durante la instrucción de esta reclamación se ha solicitado un informe a la Jefatura Provincial de Telecomunicaciones de Madrid, en el que se señala que "las operadoras de telefonía móvil presentes en la calle Joan Miró están puestas en servicio y cumplen con la normativa vigente, que asegura el cumplimiento de los niveles de emisión en la zona en relación con lo dispuesto en el RD 1066/2001, de 28 de septiembre".
   En los informes técnicos emitidos se recoge igualmente la sentencia del Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Valencia de 29 de diciembre de 2008, en la que se señala que "difícilmente un Ayuntamiento puede disponer de informes científicos con resultados válidos en la Comunidad Científica que nos digan que la colocación de una Antena de Telefonía Móvil entra dentro de las actividades calificadas a controlar por los servicios técnicos municipales".
   En este punto, se añade que "incluso sería posible que a una persona o grupo de personas se pudiera demostrar que le afecta seriamente, pero no sería suficiente ni para prohibirlas ni para tomar prevenciones en general frente a las mismas".
   "Tenemos el caso de los melocotones donde las personas alérgicas con su solo roce tienen reacciones alarmantes y no por ello se nos ha ocurrido cortar todos los melocotoneros o prohibir su venta", reza el escrito.

ELECTROSENSIBILIDAD

   Este vecino Ángel Martín J. lleva tiempo reclamando al Consistorio "responsabilidades" por lo que considera "dejación de funciones" de la Administración local ante la enfermedad que sufría su madre, 'electrosensibilidad' a las ondas, que se veía agravada, según argumenta, por las antenas de telefonía móvil de la localidad.
   Ángel siempre ha defendido su "lucha" para que todo el mundo "sea consciente de la peligrosidad de las ondas" de la telefonía móvil y de las instalaciones wifi, a raíz del fallecimiento de su madre el 28 de noviembre del pasado año.
   "Esto es un toque de atención a nivel particular y social", aseguraba hace unos meses tras manifestar que su madre sufrió una dolorosa patología que se traducía en "sentir las radiaciones con un dolor que le abrasaba la piel y la garganta". Eso llevó a sus padres a camber de domicilio en nueve ocasiones y a tener que dormir incluso en garajes.

http://www.europapress.es/madrid/noticia-pinto-desestima-reclamacion-responsabilidad-patrimonial-vecino-danos-dos-estaciones-telefonia-20140217192902.html

Pinto dismisses the claim for liability of a neighbor "damage" two telephone stations


Directory: Joan Miró Hall Pinto Radio Base Stations
City of Pinto
Photo: IRIN

MADRID, 17 Feb. (IRIN) -
 
Pinto City Council has dismissed the complaint, filed in January 2013, a neighbor called the liability of the Consistory, for damages resulting from the installation and operation of two Base Stations Mobile Phone located on the roof of the building located on Calle Joan Miró, 10.

As explained by the local government, this neighbor in its complaint sought compensation of 136,189.98 euros and has been dismissed after the technical reports and dictates about which states that "the Spanish State has exclusive jurisdiction to regulate the public domain Radio ".
 
"The Central Government has issued Royal Decree 1066/2001 of 28 September, Regulation laying down the conditions for the protection of public radio, radio emissions restrictions and health protection measures, on a scientific basis is approved that supports "out.
 
This Royal Decree establishes the Inspection and Certification of Radio installations belongs to the Technical Services of the Ministry concerned.
 
During the investigation of this claim has requested a report to the Provincial de Telecomunicaciones de Madrid, which states that "mobile operators present at the Joan Miró are put into service and comply with regulations that ensures compliance with the emission levels in the area in relation to the provisions of Royal Decree 1066/2001 of 28 September. "
 
 In the technical reports issued the judgment of the High Court of Valencia December 29, 2008 was also collected, which states that "a municipality can hardly have valid scientific reports in the Scientific Community results tell us that placing a cell tower falls within the rated control activities by municipal technical services ".
 
 At this point, adds that "even be possible for a person or group of people could be shown to seriously affect, but would not be enough either to prohibit or to take general precautions against them."
 
"Take the case of peaches where allergy sufferers with its only touch have not alarming reactions and this has happened to us all cut peach or prohibit the sale," reads the letter.
Electrosensitivity

 
This neighbor Angel Martin J. takes time claiming the Consistory "responsibility" for what he considers "dereliction of duties" of the local authority to illness endured by his mother, 'electrosensitivity' the waves, which was aggravated, he argues, by mobile phone masts locality.
 
Angel has always defended his "struggle" for everyone "is aware of the danger of the waves" of the mobile phone and wifi facilities, following the death of his mother on 28 November last year.
 
"This is a warning owners and social level," claimed a few months ago after saying that his mother suffered a painful condition that resulted in "Radiation feel a pain that seared the skin and throat." That led to his parents camber of registered nine times and having to sleep even in garages.

http://www.europapress.es/madrid/noticia-pinto-desestima-reclamacion-responsabilidad-patrimonial-vecino-danos-dos-estaciones-telefonia-20140217192902.html

"Electrosmog" Make Birds Get Lost in the City, Study Shows

"Electrosmog" Make Birds Get Lost in the City, Study Shows

May 10, 2014 08:43 AM EDT |Robert Sarkanen
Robin Bird

For the first time, a new study shows that birds exposed to AM waveband interference lose their way.
Researchers at the University of Oldenburg in Germany published a study in the coming issue ofNature, proving that the magnetic compass of robins fail when exposed to even the slightest AM radio waveband electromagnetic interference that are found in all urban areas.
Previously, it was believed that below a certain threshold value, what is known as "electrosmog" or man-made electromagnetic noise, had no impact on nature or biological processes.
This new study led by Prof. Dr. Henrik Mountsen, however, shows that a signal of even a thousandth of the limit value is enough to throw the birds off and make them lose their sense of direction and navigation. The level of electrosmog involved can be found everywhere in any urban environment.
The effects of electrosmog on birds are much less in rural environments, even in areas just one or two kilometers outside a major city's limits.
The researchers cooperated with Prof. Dr. Peter J. Hore of Oxford University in conducting the 7-year long research. Together, they found that although the level of interference required wouldn't come from just electrical lines or mobile phone networks, it would be generated by use of any electronic device.
It has been widely known that migratory birds use the Earth's magnetic field to navigate and determine their migratory direction, some birds flying thousands of miles across continents.
The research started when Mountsen's team were testing the robin bird's navigational abilities by placing them in wooden huts. They found that in the testing area, the birds were absolutely lost, until they covered the huts in aluminium. The aluminium wouldn't interfere with the Earth's magnetic field in any way, but would block out any "electrosmog" around.
To confirm the results, Mountsen had his doctorate students conduct multiple "double-blind" test where several generations of students were unknowingly engaged in performing the same tests. This was done to conclusively prove the results were the same every time without bias.
The study shows the disruptive electrosmog was generated by a much broader frequency and much lower intensity than previous studies had suggested, far below the limits set by the World Health Organization and the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection.
As a result, Mountsen expressed concern on the future survival of migratory birds, as well as the potential effects of electrosmog on human beings, which he said have yet to be investigated.
Nature magazine considered the story important enough that it will be on the covers when the issue is released on May 15.

Metabolic and genetic screening of electromagnetic hypersensitive subjects as a feasible tool for diagnostics and intervention.

 2014;2014:924184. doi: 10.1155/2014/924184. Epub 2014 Apr 9.

Metabolic and genetic screening of electromagnetic hypersensitive subjects as a feasible tool for diagnostics and intervention.

Abstract

Growing numbers of "electromagnetic hypersensitive" (EHS) people worldwide self-report severely disabling, multiorgan, non-specific symptoms when exposed to low-dose electromagnetic radiations, often associated with symptoms of multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS) and/or other environmental "sensitivity-related illnesses" (SRI). This cluster of chronic inflammatory disorders still lacks validated pathogenetic mechanism, diagnostic biomarkers, and management guidelines. We hypothesized that SRI, not being merely psychogenic, may share organic determinants of impaired detoxification of common physic-chemical stressors. Based on our previous MCS studies, we tested a panel of 12 metabolic blood redox-related parameters and of selected drug-metabolizing-enzyme gene polymorphisms, on 153 EHS, 147 MCS, and 132 control Italians, confirming MCS altered (P < 0.05-0.0001) glutathione-(GSH), GSH-peroxidase/S-transferase, and catalase erythrocyte activities. We first described comparable-though milder-metabolic pro-oxidant/proinflammatory alterations in EHS with distinctively increased plasma coenzyme-Q10 oxidation ratio. Severe depletion of erythrocyte membrane polyunsaturated fatty acids with increased ω 6/ ω 3 ratio was confirmed in MCS, but not in EHS. We also identified significantly (P = 0.003) altered distribution-versus-control of the CYP2C19∗1/∗2 SNP variants in EHS, and a 9.7-fold increased risk (OR: 95% C.I. = 1.3-74.5) of developing EHS for the haplotype (null)GSTT1 + (null)GSTM1 variants. Altogether, results on MCS and EHS strengthen our proposal to adopt this blood metabolic/genetic biomarkers' panel as suitable diagnostic tool for SRI.
PMID:
 
24812443
 
[PubMed - in process] 
PMCID:
 
PMC4000647
 
Free PMC Article

Could WiFi in schools be harming our kids?

Why are some Canadian schools installing WiFi while France is limiting exposure? (Naomi Buck for The Globe and Mail)

Could WiFi in schools be harming our kids?


Students in Lindsay Freedman’s split Grade 3/4 class at Red Willow Public School are working away on tablets, laptops and iPods. It’s Bring Your Own Device day, a regular occurrence here, and supplementing the devices brought from home are 20 school-owned iPads. Freedman walks around the classroom, marvelling at her students’ instant embrace of the online presentation app she’s just introduced. “They’re an instant motivator,” she says, referring to the tools in their hands.
Red Willow belongs to the Peel District School Board (near Toronto), one of several across Canada that have adopted WiFi throughout its schools, an embrace of 21st-century technologies designed to “ensure that our students can thrive in a future that can’t be predicted,” as Peel’s promotional brochure puts it.
Though most parents and educators celebrate the move, some are raising concerns about the possible health impacts of the radio-frequency (RF) radiation on which wireless technologies operate. Exposure levels to this kind of radiation, which fall in the same frequency bandwidth on the electro-magnetic spectrum as radios, televisions and mobile phones, continue to rise as wireless technologies become more prevalent.
Canada’s current guidelines on RF exposure are in line with those of the International Commission on Non-Ionising Radiation Protection – the largest regulatory body in this field. But many other jurisdictions have adopted considerably lower limits, either as a precautionary measure or because they view the science differently.
How is it that health agencies reach such different conclusions when faced with the same scientific evidence? Why are some Canadian schools installing WiFi while France is limiting exposure? Switzerland heavily favours wired Internet connections in schools, yet Israel is pulling it out of its lower grades altogether.
THE CAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE
While most Western bodies have deemed the scientific evidence on health effects inconclusive, many European jurisdictions are choosing to err on the side of caution until more is known. In a resolution in 2011, the Council of Europe recommended that the As Low As Reasonably Achievable (ALARA) principle be applied to electromagnetic radiation, fearing “there could be extremely high human and economic costs if early warnings are neglected.” It also condemned the “lack of reaction to known or emerging environmental or health risks and virtually systematic delays in adopting or implementing effective preventive measures.”
Lichtenstein, Italy and Belgium responded by drastically lowering their exposure guidelines. In France, a bill currently before the Senate insists on a principle of moderation where RF radiation is concerned. If passed, WiFi will be banned from maternity wards and child-care facilities, communities would have to be consulted before any installations in schools, and if installed, all routers would have to be accessible to teachers who could turn them off when not in use. Laurence Abeille, the Green MP behind the bill, had originally proposed a ban in all schools around students up to the age of six. She had to water it down to gain broad support in the National Assembly, but feels public concern in France is rising. This spring, a 32-year-old man received medical benefits from the local health authority in Essonne, south of Paris, for his electro-hypersensitivity – a first in France.
STRICT REGULATIONS
Switzerland prides itself on having among the most stringent regulations on electromagnetic radiation in the world. As of 2000, it has supplemented its exposure limits (which are in keeping with Canada’s) with much more restrictive limits for installations of power lines, television and radio transmitters, and mobile phone base-stations in well-frequented locations. The new regulations were accompanied by an aggressive public awareness campaign about the health risks of RF radiation. Swisscom, the national telecom company, promotes its line of low-radiation “Ecomode” phones and routers as “safer” – openly acknowledging the risks inherent in these devices. And for 10 years, Swisscom has been installing wired Internet connections in Swiss schools for free. Why not wireless? As company spokesman Carsten Roetz wrote in an e-mail, “because there’s no reason to put a radiation source that isn’t absolutely necessary in schools.” Of Switzerland’s 6,800 schools, Roetz estimates that fewer than 100 have opted for wireless connections.
In March of this year, the Jerusalem Post reported that the Israeli Education Ministry had ordered radiation testing in all Israeli schools, banned WiFi from pre-schools and kindergartens, and restricted its use to one hour a day for students up to Grade 3. The move came in response to persistent complaints from parents whose children suffer from some form of electromagnetic hypersensitivity.
Russia’s exposure limits for RF radiation are 100 times lower than Canada’s. While Russian schools can choose to install WiFi, they are the exceptions, says Oleg Grigoriev, chairman of the Russian National Committee on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (an expert group that reports to the Russian parliament). He says damage to children’s cognitive function caused by long-term exposure to low-strength electromagnetic fields has long since been demonstrated by Russian researchers. Russia, he explains, began experimenting with the impacts of electromagnetic fields on the nervous system a century ago, and, as a result, does not consider its approach precautionary, but rather “science-based.”
MANAGING RISK
While faced with the same scientific evidence, these countries have adopted very different rules on exposure. It’s all about managing risk. Marc Saner, a professor at the Institute for Science, Society and Policy at the University of Ottawa, affirms that scientific evidence is just one element in the multi-factorial nature of risk management in public policy. “The focus on risk reflects many things – a country’s history of science, its trade interests, the pet causes of its movie stars … Policy decisions are always a few steps away from data, there’s always an emotional component.”
Most Canadian school boards are introducing WiFi, but at a slower rate than Peel – slower not because of concern about exposure, but because installation is more complicated in older schools with thicker walls. Toronto’s school board aims to have at least partial WiFi in all its schools by 2016, and is adding zones regularly. Because WiFi exposure has been deemed safe in Canada, the expansion proceeds without notification.
Paradoxically, outside the schools’ walls, Toronto’s Board of Health insists on a “prudent avoidance policy” with respect to cell tower locations, keeping RF radiation levels in areas of the city “where people normally spend time” 100 times lower than what federal guidelines insist on – much like in Switzerland. The Board argues that as long as radiation sources in the urban environment continue to increase, the cumulative effect is unknown and caution is warranted. The policy has been in place since 1999.
In Canada, the lack of public concern about WiFi exposure in schools seems at odds with a culture of parenting that’s often called hypercautious. Here, public awareness on the issue of exposure has been mainly focused on cellphones. The science at play is beyond the reach of most citizens, and many would rather not entertain the possibility that these incredibly useful technologies may pose a risk.
“We’re not just talking about WiFi in schools,” Saner says. “We’re asking much bigger questions, like what is education? Are these devices good for society generally? Is this speed of innovation a good thing? The stakes here are huge.”
Follow us on Twitter: @Globe_Health
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/health-and-fitness/health/is-there-such-a-thing-as-too-much-wifi/article18592972/

SPANISH TELECOM ACT GIVES OPERATORS FREEDOM TO PLACE TRANSMITTERS

TELECOM ACT GIVES OPERATORS FREEDOM TO PLACE TRANSMITTERS


By Mark Nolan / 2014-05-06 19:30:45
TELECOM ACT GIVES OPERATORS FREEDOM TO PLACE TRANSMITTERS
There was an element of excitement in the announcement that the new General Telecommunications Act was approved by the Spanish government, especially the element which would guarantee 10 Meg broadband to all by 2017, but questions are now being asked about elements of implementation of the network that would allow this to happen.
The act was approved by all political groups, after a total of 179 amendments were put in place, but the biggest concern now being raised are in line with previous worries over the damage caused by harmful radiation emitted from transmitters and telecoms networks.
As reported in November of last year, the Los Verdes green party of Orihuela announced plans to create an ordinance to regulate the installation of mobile phone masts, with the intention of removing all unlicensed antennas and transmitter sites, with a lot of detail provided by the Councillor for the Environment on the dangers associated with these masts. Similarly, in April of this year, we reported how the Planning Department of Torrevieja town hall had ordered Telefónica to remove an antenna located on a green area of the urbanization El Chaparral-La Siesta, because it didn´t have the appropriate licences in place for its location.
Now, as part of the newly approved act, telecommunication companies are free to install these mobile phone masts anywhere they choose, and on any roof top deemed necessary, without either the residents or the council having a say or objection.
Critics are now saying that the new law has been “tailor-made” to facilitate the implementation of the more modern 4G mobile networks in all urban areas, but that will also aggravate and increase the health risks associated with these powerful transmitters.
The modern world sees most people attached to their mobile phones, perhaps not prepared to either give them up or suffer the consequences of a reduction in network coverage, but those who have filed cases based on damage to health may see another side to this aggressive act.
The only requirement within the act is that the operators must ask permission from the Industry Ministry before placing their equipment on the residential or commercial building of their choice, but the justification of being of commercial benefit is all that is likely to be needed over the damage to health, or the aesthetics of an area where those who object will now be powerless to act.

EU to bug every car in UK with tracker chips – and Ministers admit they are powerless to stop the Big Brother technology

EU to bug every car in UK with tracker chips – and Ministers admit they are powerless to stop the Big Brother technology 

  • Under EU plans, every new car sold in UK will have a 'black box' device
  • Gadget contains a phone-like SIM card which tracks drivers' movements
  • Designed to help emergency services find vehicles in the event of crash
  • Government believes the device will add at least £100 to the cost of cars
  • Officials also fear it could be used by police to monitor motorists' moves
  • But ministers admit they are powerless to stop Big Brother technology
  • All new car models will have to include 'eCall' device from October 2015


Every new car sold in Britain will have to have a ‘black box’ device fitted to track drivers’ movements from next year, under plans being imposed by the European Union.  

Despite serious concerns about privacy and cost, UK ministers admit they are powerless to stop the Big Brother technology being forced on motorists and car makers. 

The Government believes the gadget, designed to help emergency services find crashed vehicles, will add at least £100 to the cost of vehicles without providing significant safety improvements.

New technology: Every new car sold in Britain will have to have a 'black box' device fitted to track drivers' movements from next year, under plans being imposed by the European Union. Above, how the device works
New technology: Every new car sold in Britain will have to have a 'black box' device fitted to track drivers' movements from next year, under plans being imposed by the European Union. Above, how the device works

Officials also fear the scheme, known as eCall, could be used by police or insurance companies to monitor motorists’ every move.   

The European Commission has ruled that by October next year, all new cars and vans sold across Europe must be fitted with the technology, which contains a mobile phone-like SIM card designed to transmit the vehicle’s location to emergency services in the event of a crash.
But The Mail on Sunday has seen official correspondence from the Department of Transport showing the UK’s opposition to the policy, which could lead to the ‘constant tracking’ of vehicles. 

In a letter to MPs, Transport Minister Robert Goodwill writes: ‘The basis for our opposition is that costs to the UK outweigh the benefits. 

Concern: Official correspondence from the Department of Transport shows the UK's opposition to the policy. Transport Minister Robert Goodwill (pictured) claims the costs of the device to Britain 'outweigh the benefits'
Concern: Official correspondence from the Department of Transport shows the UK's opposition to the policy. Transport Minister Robert Goodwill (pictured) claims the costs of the device to Britain 'outweigh the benefits'

‘Unfortunately, there is very little support for the UK position and no possibility of blocking this legislation. We are working with other member states to minimize the potential burdens on manufacturers and the potential cost to consumers. 

‘With regard to the rules on privacy and data protection, other member states have expressed  similar concerns to us, about the potential for constant tracking of vehicles via the eCall system.’

Emma Carr, of civil liberties group Big Brother Watch, said last night: ‘Motorists will not be comfortable forcibly having a black box installed which is capable of recording and transmitting their exact location when they are driving.’

New model: Some car manufacturers, including BMW and Volvo, already include eCall devices in their latest models. However, voluntary take-up has been low across the industry. Above, the BMW i3
New model: Some car manufacturers, including BMW and Volvo, already include eCall devices in their latest models. However, voluntary take-up has been low across the industry. Above, the BMW i3

Some car manufacturers, including BMW and Volvo, already include eCall devices in their latest models. 
An SOS button near the dashboard, linked to a SIM card, allows drivers to call 999 quickly. And if airbags are deployed it automatically sends a text message to emergency services with the car’s location – as well as its unique vehicle ID number.

Voluntary take-up has been low across the industry so the EU ruled all new car models must include eCall from October 1, 2015. Motorists will be unable to switch it off and it will be tested in MoT checks.

‘Unfortunately, there is very little support for the UK position and no possibility of blocking this legislation'
Robert Goodwill MP
The EU Parliament voted it through last month and a draft of the law is due to be published next week before it is agreed by the EU Commission. 

Britain is trying to push back the deadline by two years. 

The UK also hopes the new text will include assurances on the privacy risks of eCall, which were highlighted in a European Parliament legal report earlier this year.

The study said manufacturers will want to include ‘value added services’ for the SOS devices, such as sharing the data with insurers and recovery firms.

A separate study by the EU Data Protection Supervisor warns of the ‘potential intrusiveness’ of eCall given that it operates on the same basis as mobile phones and ‘potentially enables the constant collection of the vehicle’s geolocation’. It urges ‘stricter safeguards’ against ‘unlawful’ use of personal data.

Brussels insists eCall will save 2,500 lives a year by speeding up emergency services response times.


Saturday, May 10, 2014

Cargo Cult Science

Cargo Cult Science

Richard Feynman

From a Caltech commencement address given in 1974 
Also in Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!


During the Middle Ages there were all kinds of crazy ideas, such as that a piece of of rhinoceros horn would increase potency. Then a method was discovered for separating the ideas--which was to try one to see if it worked, and if it didn't work, to eliminate it. This method became organized, of course, into science. And it developed very well, so that we are now in the scientific age. It is such a scientific age, in fact, that we have difficulty in understanding how witch doctors could ever have existed, when nothing that they proposed ever really worked--or very little of it did.

But even today I meet lots of people who sooner or later get me into a conversation about UFO's, or astrology, or some form of mysticism, expanded consciousness, new types of awareness, ESP, and so forth. And I've concluded that it's not a scientific world.

Most people believe so many wonderful things that I decided to investigate why they did. And what has been referred to as my curiosity for investigation has landed me in a difficulty where I found so much junk that I'm overwhelmed. First I started out by investigating various ideas of mysticism and mystic experiences. I went into isolation tanks and got many hours of hallucinations, so I know something about that. Then I went to Esalen, which is a hotbed of this kind of thought (it's a wonderful place; you should go visit there). Then I became overwhelmed. I didn't realize how MUCH there was.

At Esalen there are some large baths fed by hot springs situated on a ledge about thirty feet above the ocean. One of my most pleasurable experiences has been to sit in one of those baths and watch the waves crashing onto the rocky slope below, to gaze into the clear blue sky above, and to study a beautiful nude as she quietly appears and settles into the bath with me.

One time I sat down in a bath where there was a beatiful girl sitting with a guy who didn't seem to know her. Right away I began thinking, "Gee! How am I gonna get started talking to this beautiful nude woman?"

I'm trying to figure out what to say, when the guy says to her, "I'm, uh, studying massage. Could I practice on you?" "Sure," she says. They get out of the bath and she lies down on a massage table nearby. I think to myself, "What a nifty line! I can never think of anything like that!" He starts to rub her big toe. "I think I feel it," he says. "I feel a kind of dent--is that the pituitary?" I blurt out, "You're a helluva long way from the pituitary, man!" They looked at me, horrified -- I had blown my cover -- and said, "It's reflexology!" I quickly closed my eyes and appeared to be meditating.

That's just an example of the kind of things that overwhelm me. I also looked into extrasensory perception, and PSI phenomena, and the latest craze there was Uri Geller, a man who is supposed to be able to bend keys by rubbing them with his finger. So I went to his hotel room, on his invitation, to see a demonstration of both mindreading and bending keys. He didn't do any mindreading that succeeded; nobody can read my mind, I guess. And my boy held a key and Geller rubbed it, and nothing happened. Then he told us it works better under water, and so you can picture all of us standing in the bathroom with the water turned on and the key under it, and him rubbing the key with his finger. Nothing happened. So I was unable to investigate that phenomenon.

But then I began to think, what else is there that we believe? (And I thought then about the witch doctors, and how easy it would have been to check on them by noticing that nothing really worked.) So I found things that even more people believe, such as that we have some knowledge of how to educate. There are big schools of reading methods and mathematics methods, and so forth, but if you notice, you'll see the reading scores keep going down--or hardly going up--in spite of the fact that we continually use these same people to improve the methods. There's a witch doctor remedy that doesn't work. It ought to be looked into; how do they know that their method should work? Another example is how to treat criminals. We obviously have made no progress--lots of theory, but no progress--in decreasing the amount of crime by the method that we use to handle criminals.

Yet these things are said to be scientific. We study them. And I think ordinary people with commonsense ideas are intimidated by this pseudoscience. A teacher who has some good idea of how to teach her children to read is forced by the school system to do it some other way--or is even fooled by the school system into thinking that her method is not necessarily a good one. Or a parent of bad boys, after disciplining them in one way or another, feels guilty for the rest of her life because she didn't do "the right thing," according to the experts.

So we really ought to look into theories that don't work, and science that isn't science.
I think the educational and psychological studies I mentioned are examples of what I would like to call cargo cult science. In the South Seas there is a cargo cult of people. During the war they saw airplanes with lots of good materials, and they want the same thing to happen now. So they've arranged to make things like runways, to put fires along the sides of the runways, to make a wooden hut for a man to sit in, with two wooden pieces on his head to headphones and bars of bamboo sticking out like antennas--he's the controller--and they wait for the airplanes to land. They're doing everything right. The form is perfect. It looks exactly the way it looked before. But it doesn't work. No airplanes land. So I call these things cargo cult science, because they follow all the apparent precepts and forms of scientific investigation, but they're missing something essential, because the planes don't land.

Now it behooves me, of course, to tell you what they're missing. But it would be just about as difficult to explain to the South Sea islanders how they have to arrange things so that they get some wealth in their system. It is not something simple like telling them how to improve the shapes of the earphones. But there is one feature I notice that is generally missing in cargo cult science. That is the idea that we all hope you have learned in studying science in school--we never say explicitly what this is, but just hope that you catch on by all the examples of scientific investigation. It is interesting, therefore, to bring it out now and speak of it explicitly. It's a kind of scientific integrity, a principle of scientific thought that corresponds to a kind of utter honesty--a kind of leaning over backwards. For example, if you're doing an experiment, you should report everything that you think might make it invalid--not only what you think is right about it: other causes that could possibly explain your results; and things you thought of that you've eliminated by some other experiment, and how they worked--to make sure the other fellow can tell they have been eliminated.

Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given, if you know them. You must do the best you can--if you know anything at all wrong, or possibly wrong--to explain it. If you make a theory, for example, and advertise it, or put it out, then you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it. There is also a more subtle problem. When you have put a lot of ideas together to make an elaborate theory, you want to make sure, when explaining what it fits, that those things it fits are not just the things that gave you the idea for the theory; but that the finished theory makes something else come out right, in addition.

In summary, the idea is to give all of the information to help others to judge the value of your contribution; not just the information that leads to judgement in one particular direction or another.

The easiest way to explain this idea is to contrast it, for example, with advertising. Last night I heard that Wesson oil doesn't soak through food. Well, that's true. It's not dishonest; but the thing I'm talking about is not just a matter of not being dishonest; it's a matter of scientific integrity, which is another level. The fact that should be added to that advertising statement is that no oils soak through food, if operated at a certain temperature. If operated at another temperature, they all will--including Wesson oil. So it's the implication which has been conveyed, not the fact, which is true, and the difference is what we have to deal with.

We've learned from experience that the truth will come out. Other experimenters will repeat your experiment and find out whether you were wrong or right. Nature's phenomena will agree or they'll disagree with your theory. And, although you may gain some temporary fame and excitement, you will not gain a good reputation as a scientist if you haven't tried to be very careful in this kind of work. And it's this type of integrity, this kind of care not to fool yourself, that is missing to a large extent in much of the research in cargo cult science.

A great deal of their difficulty is, of course, the difficulty of the subject and the inapplicability of the scientific method to the subject. Nevertheless, it should be remarked that this is not the only difficulty. That's why the planes don't land--but they don't land.

We have learned a lot from experience about how to handle some of the ways we fool ourselves. One example: Millikan measured the charge on an electron by an experiment with falling oil drops, and got an answer which we now know not to be quite right. It's a little bit off because he had the incorrect value for the viscosity of air. It's interesting to look at the history of measurements of the charge of an electron, after Millikan. If you plot them as a function of time, you find that one is a little bit bigger than Millikan's, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, until finally they settle down to a number which is higher.

Why didn't they discover the new number was higher right away? It's a thing that scientists are ashamed of--this history--because it's apparent that people did things like this: When they got a number that was too high above Millikan's, they thought something must be wrong--and they would look for and find a reason why something might be wrong. When they got a number close to Millikan's value they didn't look so hard. And so they eliminated the numbers that were too far off, and did other things like that. We've learned those tricks nowadays, and now we don't have that kind of a disease.

But this long history of learning how to not fool ourselves--of having utter scientific integrity--is, I'm sorry to say, something that we haven't specifically included in any particular course that I know of. We just hope you've caught on by osmosis

The first principle is that you must not fool yourself--and you are the easiest person to fool. So you have to be very careful about that. After you've not fooled yourself, it's easy not to fool other scientists. You just have to be honest in a conventional way after that.
I would like to add something that's not essential to the science, but something I kind of believe, which is that you should not fool the layman when you're talking as a scientist. I am not trying to tell you what to do about cheating on your wife, or fooling your girlfriend, or something like that, when you're not trying to be a scientist, but just trying to be an ordinary human being. We'll leave those problems up to you and your rabbi. I'm talking about a specific, extra type of integrity that is not lying, but bending over backwards to show how you're maybe wrong, that you ought to have when acting as a scientist. And this is our responsibility as scientists, certainly to other scientists, and I think to laymen.

For example, I was a little surprised when I was talking to a friend who was going to go on the radio. He does work on cosmology and astronomy, and he wondered how he would explain what the applications of his work were. "Well," I said, "there aren't any." He said, "Yes, but then we won't get support for more research of this kind." I think that's kind of dishonest. If you're representing yourself as a scientist, then you should explain to the layman what you're doing-- and if they don't support you under those circumstances, then that's their decision.

One example of the principle is this: If you've made up your mind to test a theory, or you want to explain some idea, you should always decide to publish it whichever way it comes out. If we only publish results of a certain kind, we can make the argument look good. We must publish BOTH kinds of results.

I say that's also important in giving certain types of government advice. Supposing a senator asked you for advice about whether drilling a hole should be done in his state; and you decide it would be better in some other state. If you don't publish such a result, it seems to me you're not giving scientific advice. You're being used. If your answer happens to come out in the direction the government or the politicians like, they can use it as an argument in their favor; if it comes out the other way, they don't publish at all. That's not giving scientific advice.

Other kinds of errors are more characteristic of poor science. When I was at Cornell, I often talked to the people in the psychology department. One of the students told me she wanted to do an experiment that went something like this--it had been found by others that under certain circumstances, X, rats did something, A. She was curious as to whether, if she changed the circumstances to Y, they would still do A. So her proposal was to do the experiment under circumstances Y and see if they still did A.

I explained to her that it was necessary first to repeat in her laboratory the experiment of the other person--to do it under condition X to see if she could also get result A, and then change to Y and see if A changed. Then she would know the the real difference was the thing she thought she had under control.

She was very delighted with this new idea, and went to her professor. And his reply was, no, you cannot do that, because the experiment has already been done and you would be wasting time. This was in about 1947 or so, and it seems to have been the general policy then to not try to repeat psychological experiments, but only to change the conditions and see what happened.

Nowadays, there's a certain danger of the same thing happening, even in the famous field of physics. I was shocked to hear of an experiment being done at the big accelerator at the National Accelerator Laboratory, where a person used deuterium. In order to compare his heavy hydrogen results to what might happen with light hydrogen, he had to use data from someone else's experiment on light hydrogen, which was done on different apparatus. When asked why, he said it was because he couldn't get time on the program (because there's so little time and it's such expensive apparatus) to do the experiment with light hydrogen on this apparatus because there wouldn't be any new result. And so the men in charge of programs at NAL are so anxious for new results, in order to get more money to keep the thing going for public relations purposes, they are destroying--possibly--the value of the experiments themselves, which is the whole purpose of the thing. It is often hard for the experimenters there to complete their work as their scientific integrity demands.

All experiments in psychology are not of this type, however. For example, there have been many experiments running rats through all kinds of mazes, and so on--with little clear result. But in 1937 a man named Young did a very interesting one. He had a long corridor with doors all along one side where the rats came in, and doors along the other side where the food was. He wanted to see if he could train the rats to go in at the third door down from wherever he started them off. No. The rats went immediately to the door where the food had been the time before.

The question was, how did the rats know, because the corridor was so beautifully built and so uniform, that this was the same door as before? Obviously there was something about the door that was different from the other doors. So he painted the doors very carefully, arranging the textures on the faces of the doors exactly the same. Still the rats could tell. Then he thought maybe the rats were smelling the food, so he used chemicals to change the smell after each run. Still the rats could tell. Then he realized the rats might be able to tell by seeing the lights and the arrangement in the laboratory like any commonsense person. So he covered the corridor, and still the rats could tell.

He finally found that they could tell by the way the floor sounded when they ran over it. And he could only fix that by putting his corridor in sand. So he covered one after another of all possible clues and finally was able to fool the rats so that they had to learn to go in the third door. If he relaxed any of his conditions, the rats could tell.

Now, from a scientific standpoint, that is an A-number-one experiment. That is the experiment that makes rat-running experiments sensible, because it uncovers that clues that the rat is really using-- not what you think it's using. And that is the experiment that tells exactly what conditions you have to use in order to be careful and control everything in an experiment with rat-running.

I looked up the subsequent history of this research. The next experiment, and the one after that, never referred to Mr. Young. They never used any of his criteria of putting the corridor on sand, or being very careful. They just went right on running the rats in the same old way, and paid no attention to the great discoveries of Mr. Young, and his papers are not referred to, because he didn't discover anything about the rats. In fact, he discovered all the things you have to do to discover something about rats. But not paying attention to experiments like that is a characteristic example of cargo cult science.
Another example is the ESP experiments of Mr. Rhine, and other people. As various people have made criticisms--and they themselves have made criticisms of their own experiements--they improve the techniques so that the effects are smaller, and smaller, and smaller until they gradually disappear. All the para-psychologists are looking for some experiment that can be repeated--that you can do again and get the same effect--statistically, even. They run a million rats--no, it's people this time--they do a lot of things are get a certain statistical effect. Next time they try it they don't get it any more. And now you find a man saying that is is an irrelevant demand to expect a repeatable experiment. This is science?

This man also speaks about a new institution, in a talk in which he was resigning as Director of the Institute of Parapsychology. And, in telling people what to do next, he says that one of things they have to do is be sure the only train students who have shown their ability to get PSI results to an acceptable extent--not to waste their time on those ambitious and interested students who get only chance results. It is very dangerous to have such a policy in teaching--to teach students only how to get certain results, rather than how to do an experiment with scientific integrity.

So I have just one wish for you--the good luck to be somewhere where you are free to maintain the kind of integrity I have described, and where you do not feel forced by a need to maintain your position in the organization, or financial support, or so on, to lose your integrity. May you have that freedom.

[photo] -- Richard Feynman

http://neurotheory.columbia.edu/~ken/cargo_cult.html