Tuesday, July 03, 2012

Cablevision Doggedly Pushes Wi-Fi


Cablevision Doggedly Pushes Wi-Fi

Launches Hotspot-Finder App, Debuts Ad Campaign with 'HotSpot the Dog'

By Todd Spangler -- Multichannel News, 6/26/2012 12:35:03 PM

Cablevision Systems launched a new app for Apple mobile devices to let customers find the nearest Optimum Wi-Fi hotspot and is kicking off an animated ad campaign featuring "HotSpot the Dog," who schools his dopey owner on the benefits of the wireless service.
Optimum - HotSpot the DogThe MSO's Wi-Fi service, which comprises more than 35,000 indoor and outdoor access points across the New York metro area, is available to Optimum Online customers for no additional cost.
Cablevision's renewed Wi-Fi marketing push comes after the company last month teamed up with Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox Communications and Bright House Networks to let each other's high-speed Internet customers access their respective Wi-Fi networks. That initiative, dubbed CableWiFi, provides the subscribers of participating MSOs reciprocal access to more than 50,000 Wi-Fi hotspots across the U.S.
The new app is available as a free download in the Apple iTunes App Store for iPhone, iPod touch and iPad devices. Users can conduct quick, advanced, and "near me" searches for hotspots whether or not their iOS device is connected to the Internet. 
Optimum WiFi Finder AppIn the "HotSpot the Dog" ad, the canine tells his owner, Ben, that he wants to bring his smartphone along on a walk -- but Ben objects that the dog's wireless data charges are out of control. "Don't worry about it, our town has dozens of Optimum hotspots," the dog replies. The ad can be viewed athttp://youtu.be/Vzh3-5jKEeM.
"Optimum WiFi is an important extension of our broadband service, and we want to make it as easy as possible for our customers to find and use this free access when away from their wired home or business locations," Cablevision vice president of wireless development Timothy Farrell said in a statement. "Our new app will help guide customers to the nearest Optimum WiFi hotspot, just like their own personal version of HotSpot the dog, who helps his owner Ben stay connected through Optimum WiFi."
The Optimum Wi-Fi network provides speeds of up to 15 Megabits per second downstream and 4 Mbps upstream, which Cablevision noted is much faster than 3G data services. According to the MSO, customers use its Wi-Fi more than 1 million times each day to connect to the Internet.

Health risks with Wi-Fi


Health risks with Wi-Fi

wi-fi-making you sick 

There are two components to a Wi-Fi router that can be hazardous to our health and well-being
: 

1)it is generating chaotic EMF signals and 

2)It is broadcasting on a frequency close to that used by our bodies - so can "jam" us. 

This is Murray Laird’s experience of the health effects from Wi-Fi: 

“I have recently experienced two unpleasant situations relative to Wi-Fi. 1st situation was at my son's house when he offed his i-pad for me to view an app. As soon as I brought the i-pad within close proximity to me I developed a headache. Conversely as soon as I gave the i-pad back the headache disappeared. 

Note: I am not a person that has experienced many headaches in my life under normal conditions. The second circumstance was in the last couple of weeks in my own home. My sister had asked me to assist with a computer problem. I activated my Wi-Fi. At the same time, my daughter decided to use her i-pad to communicate with her partner in England. As I went to sort out my sister's p.c. problem (laptop), I experienced a wave of nausea which made me totally unable to attend to her problem. I drove away from my house (leaving my son to attend to the p.c. problem), to attend to another matter. As I drove off, I wondered if I was well enough to drive, such was my feeling at the time. I recovered, returned home, had an instant headache upon entering my house which disappeared as soon as I turned off my Wi-Fi. The above situations are the worst that I have experienced but I usually feel uncomfortable in a Wi-Fi presence. 

I have had a life exposed to electricity as an electrical contractor plus my early training was spent in high voltage situations. I am a trained building biologist who specializes in assisting people who are exposed to e.m.f emissions. It is possible that I have a greater sensitivity than most. 

I work as an electronics technician in Hamilton. There is a massive build-up in the use of Wi-Fi on both the Hamilton campuses. At a meeting with electrical staff, last week. I outlined my experiences and requested that Wi-Fi be minimized in a new building to be constructed for the Schools of Trades and Engineering. As expected, a number of staff were skeptical although they are aware that I have knowledge in this area. I have demonstrated areas of concern to them and some have admitted that they can't get electrical experiments to work correctly in these areas (what a surprise). The electrical manager has agreed to bring my concerns to the architects so hopefully someone will take notice. 

Last year 2 students (22 & 25 years old) died of a heart attack and a 35 year old died of a brain tumour. All spent most of their day in a wireless environment in front of computers. One actually died on site while the other two died within two hours of leaving work. In another incident, my daughter's partner, a computer technician, who spent most of his waking hours in front of a computer, died at age 36 from a heart attack. He was in reasonable physical shape and was about to engage in a ju jitsu lesson. Are these incidents just a coincidence?” 

Thanks to Murray for sharing his expertise and experiences. It is people like him that make a difference. 

Margie 

http://www.lifeenergysolutions.com/blog/wi-fi-health-risks/

Letters: Opposed to cell tower


I am opposed to the communications tower application 6631 and 6633 Sooke Road for health reasons and others.

My understanding has been that the District of Sooke wants to create high density in the downtown core where I live. Mariners Village Phase 1 is high density and is only metres from our property line. I am concerned that Mariners Village property owners, as well as tenants and workers, within the 100 metre distance of the proposed communications tower have not been properly notified or are even aware of the health issues related to this proposal. I have called and spoken to people and they know nothing about it.
There is strong evidence that electromagnetic radiation from cell phone towers is damaging to human (and animal) health. Over 100 scientists and physicians at Boston and Harvard Universities Schools of Public Health have called cell phone towers a radiation hazard.

The damage from radiation exposure accumulates over many years, but the breakdown in health happens only after all body defenses and repair mechanisms have been exhausted. For some people, short term effects from cell tower radiation exposure may include headaches, sleep disorders, poor memory, mental excitation, confusion, anxiety, depression, appetite disturbance and listlessness. Sufficient information has not been given to those living and working near this proposed tower.

A study performed by doctors in Germany have found that those living within 400 metres of a cell tower had a newly-diagnosed cancer rate three times higher than those who lived further away. Breast cancer topped the list, but cancers of the prostate, pancreas, bowel, skin melanoma, lung and blood cancer were all increased. (Naila Study)
I am surprised and shocked that our city planner would even consider this application. I am also curious to know the amount of money Alcatel-Lucent has enticed the property owner with.. Does the property owner live at the address of the proposed tower? What amount of money is worth putting our health at risk? We are talking about our downtown core where people live and work this is a very serious issue that will require responsible governing.

Real estate in the area is at risk as no one with knowledge would buy near a cell tower. Tourism will be affected as a 40-metre tower (132 ft) in the middle of our town does not beautify Sooke in any way. Our community has always attracted travelers because of its unique natural environment. We have clean air beautiful views, gardens and an opportunity to show the world we are respectful and responsible people living here.
I have lived in Sooke in the same house for over 32 years. I had a Teahouse and B&B in my home for 25 years. I have guest books with hundreds of signatures from people from all over the world with comments about how beautiful it is here. Two of my grandchildren live adjacent to our property within 50 metres of this disastrous proposal. What chance has my one- month-old grandson against this radiation.

Why should the people living and working in downtown Sooke be put at risk?

I request that council do what they can to stop this.

Sylvia Hallgren
Sooke


Public sector sick days cost $1B a year


Public sector sick days cost $1B a year



Posted: Jun 20, 2012 9:03 PM ET



A confidential government report obtained by CBC News reveals federal workers have been booking off sick in record numbers, costing Canadian taxpayers more than $1 billion a year in lost wages alone.
The internal Treasury Board report indicates federal public servants are staying home an average of 18 working days a year, or almost a full month off the job.
That is about 2½ times the average rate of absenteeism in Canadian private industry, and almost twice the level of sick leave and disability claims in the rest of the public sector.
This apparent epidemic of bureaucratic no-shows means that on an average weekday, more federal public servants are off sick than there are employees at Ford Canada and General Motors combined.
Statistics over the past decade show absenteeism is a growing problem, and experts say the Conservative government's current job cuts will only make matters much worse.
Most workers in the federal public service get up to 15 days of fully paid sick leave per year, and on average, they are calling in sick for 12 of them.
In most areas of the government, employees can bank unused sick leave for future needs.
According to one informed estimate, public servants are currently sitting on about $5.2-billion worth of accumulated sick leave, a potential tidal wave of future absenteeism.

Long-term disability adds to costs

Federal employees whose illnesses outlast their regular sick leave benefits may also be entitled to long-term disability coverage.
The confidential report shows the use of long-term disability benefits is also increasing, accounting for the equivalent of another six days a year of lost work per government employee.
The combination of regular sick leave and long-term disability adds up to an average absenteeism of 18 days a year per employee.
The report estimates that on any given day, there are about 6,000 federal workers collecting disability benefits equal to 70 per cent of their regular income. (The report does not include employees of Crown corporations.)
Almost half of them are on leave for stress, depression or other mental health issues.
Gregory Thomas, head of the Canadian Taxpayers' Federation, calls the situation "outrageous."
"We know the population isn't sick 18 days a year; it doesn't make sense.
"The government's got to start treating this money like it's their own money, and they've got to insist that if people are healthy, they come to work. And if people are sick, you've got to make sure they are sick."

Absenteeism expected to get worse

The 86-page report completed a year ago is part of a government-wide review called the Disability Management Initiative, an attempt by the Harper administration to come to grips with soaring absenteeism in the public service.
The report says so much absenteeism already costs Canadian taxpayers more than $1 billion a year.
Experts say the situation is likely to get worse.
The Harper government has announced it is cutting about 19,500 jobs across the federal public service over the next three years — coincidentally, almost exactly the number of federal workers off sick on any given day.
The report warns cuts inherently "place more strain and additional burdens on employees who are present in the workplace, causing yet more disability."
That view is shared by workplace health experts and by union officials.
Linda Duxbury, a professor at Carleton University's Sprott School of Business and one of the country's leading specialists in workplace health and absenteeism, said the record levels of sick leave shouldn't come as a surprise.
"We know in fact downsizing, restructuring, re-engineering, losing jobs — it is incredibly hard on people; it is hard on their psyche, hard on their mental health.
Gary Corbett, head of the Professional Institute of the Public Service, the union representing government scientists, engineers and other professionals, blames the Harper government's approach to downsizing the public service for creating uncertainty among employees.
"It puts a lot of stress on people."
The government's Disability Management Initiative includes representatives from the public service unions, and was supposed to lay the groundwork for a complete overhaul of federal sick leave and disability programs across the bureaucracy.
But no one seems to know what has happened to the whole initiative.
Treasury Board officials refused to provide any information on the initiative — or anything else to do with government absenteeism.
Senior officials at the two largest public service unions say no one in their ranks has even seen the report.
Indeed, a year after the report was completed, there is no evidence it has prompted the government to make any changes at all.

Should the FCC look for a link between mobile phones and cancer?


Should the FCC look for a link between mobile phones and cancer?

A man talks on a cell phone in an urban area
The FCC may re-examine standards for the amount of radiation emitted by cell phones. But hasn't any connection between cell phones and brain cancer been put to rest? Why does the FCC need to get into this again?

Federal Communications Commission chair Julius Genachowski has put forward a proposal that the agency review its regulations governing the amount of energy that can be emitted by mobile phones. Although a spokesperson characterized the potential review as “routine,” the possible move has reignited concerns over a potential link between mobile phone usage and some types of brain and head cancers. Any re-examination could have broad effects on the mobile industry, since essentially all mobile phone and portable device makers have to comply with FCC requirements on emissions. There’s even a possibility the FCC could look at different sets of standards: one for adults, and another more-stringent set of guidelines aimed at children, whose developing bodies may be more at risk.

That sounds well and good — after all, looking out for the public’s well-being is part of the agency’s job. However, the vast majority of scientific studies to date have found no relationship between cell phone use and cancer. Why is the FCC opening up this can of worms again?

The FCC’s role

cell tower [Shutterstock noolwlee]
Here’s a funny thing: there are no universal federal standards that layout supposedly-safe levels of exposure to radio frequency (RF) energy — the sort of thing emitted by cell phones and other devices. That said, a bunch of separate federal agencies have their own takes on the issue, including the National Institute for Occupational Safely and Health, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Food and Drug Administration, and (of course) the FCC. The FCC is, of course, concerned with communications devices, while agencies like the FDA are more concerned with devices like microwave ovens, NIOSH tends to look at things like video display terminals in workplaces, and the EPA looks at levels of RF emissions in the general environment, as well as things like RFID tags and so-called “smart meters” that report power usage information back to utilities using wireless technologies.

These federal agencies generally have few (if any) physicians, biologists, or other experts on their staff conducting research to form their guidelines, so they rely on work from non-governmental organizations like the the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP) and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers(IEEE). But they really don’t look at the standards all that often. The FCC last set regulations covering emissions from mobile phones back in 1996 — the document is old enough that the FCC released it in WordPerfect format. If it’s “routine,” it’s not a very regular routine. But compared to other agencies, the FCC is kind of on the ball: The EPA last looked at RF emissions way back in 1979.

What are the limits?

microwave hazard [Shutterstock XAOC]
For mobile phones and other devices designed to be used close to the human body, the FCC and most other agencies deals with RF emissions in terms of specific absorption rate, or SAR. The FCC’s maximum “safe” SAR for RF emissions from a mobile phone or similar device is 1.6 Watts per kilogram, averaged over one gram of tissue. (This is actually a bit more restrictive than similar limits in Europe, which are currently 2 Watts per kilogram averaged over 10 grams of tissue.) As a point of comparison, measured SAR of RF radiation from a microwave oven is about 8 Watts per kilogram if you are literally pressing yourself up against it while its operating. From a distance of just 5 cm — say, peering through the window to see if your macaroni and cheese has exploded — the SAR from that same microwave oven drops to less than 0.3 Watts per kilogram.

That said, the concern with mobile phones is that literally hundreds of millions of people are pressing RF-emitting devices to within a centimeter or so of their brains, sometimes for several hours a day. As yet, even longitudinal scientific studies attempting to track individuals’ health and cell phone use over decades have not linked any known health problems to exposure to RF energy from mobile phones. However, you can’t prove a negative, so studies haven’t disproven any connection either, and there’s enough variation in some studies that researchers and activists aren’t willing to rule out of the possibility of a relationship, however slight. And if there is a connection, we may not be seeing signs yet. Back in 1996, only about 44 million Americans had mobile phones; today, most industry estimates put the figure over 330 million. Given how long it can take cancers like glioma and acoustic nueroma to develop, it may be many years before any long term effects start to become apparent, at which point, it would be too late for a couple generations of mobile phone users to avoid problems.

Mobile phones as a possible carcinogen

quit smoking
Most forms of cancer develop as a result of damage to DNA. Plenty of things can lead to DNA damage: Sometimes it even occurs “naturally” when cells goof up during the complex chemical processes involved in DNA replication. The copying process is near-perfect, but not wholly perfect. That’s one way we get mutations. Sometimes mutations are beneficial; sometimes they’re cancer.
Sometimes substances interfere with the DNA replication process, inserting themselves into the process or preventing certain chemical bondings from taking place. (These substances are “carcinogens.” Sometimes they’re exotic chemicals, sometimes they’re everyday materials like oxygen with a spare electron just waiting to latch on to something convenient.) Ionizing radiation — like x-rays, gamma rays, and radon — can also damage DNA directly. This is an oversimplification, but think of ionizing radiation as bullets smashing into DNA. DNA replication takes place, the original DNA is broken, so the copies are broken too. All these things increase risk of cancer.
Radio frequency (RF) radiation is non-ionizing. Basically, it has no bullets. There is currently no scientific evidence that RF energy increases cancer risk. None.
The only known biological impact of RF energy being absorbed by tissue is heating. This is actually the process by which microwave ovens work, albeit at a much higher power levels than mobile phones. The heating impact of mobile phone use is not enough to raise human body temperature, although it might be enough to slightly raise the temperature of tissue closest to the phone. A 2011 study found preliminary evidence that during long mobile phone calls (50 minutes) brain tissue on the side of users’ heads with the mobile phone metabolized more sugar (glucose) than the opposite side of the brain. But there is as yet no known significance to this finding — assuming it holds up.

So why the worry?

children smartphone
No amount of research will be able to prove there’s no connection between mobile phones and cancer, so there will always be room for doubt. Not all people are created equal — your mileage may vary, as the saying goes. RF energy and heating may not have any known general impact on tissue, but testing cannot have accounted for every substance, medication, or combination thereof that could be floating around a person’s physiology or bloodstream. Who knows: Maybe metabolizing more glucose while on a particular medication can produce a slight uptick in a nucleotide that, rarely, can interfere with normal DNA replication? No one can say. Possibilities like this and inconsistent results from a handful of long-term studies are what led the International Agency for Research on Cancer (part of the World Health Organization) to classify cell phones alongside things like gasoline and DDT as “possible” carcinogens. The agency did not claim there is a connection, but called for more research. However, other organizations like the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation conclude (PDF) that scientific evidence is increasingly against any link between mobile phone use and brain tumors in adults. But there’s still very little data on people who have used cell phones for more than 15 years.
Children, however, might be another matter. Children’s brains are undergoing rapid development and could conceivably be more sensitive to RF energy than healthy adults. The issue of children is usually where the debate about cell phone emissions becomes most forceful, since parents and societies are understandably very sensitive about any issue potentially impacting child welfare. Children are also one area where current scientific research is lacking — longitudinal studies to date don’t have much data to work with on childhood tumors. However, one of the only major studies to date, the CEFALO study conducted in Sweden, Norway, Denmark, and Switzerland, found no connection between brain tumors and cell phone use in children aged 7 to 19.

Upshot

The FCC’s proposed review of RF emission standards can hardly be classified as “routine,” since they basically never seem to do it. However, in light of the current body scientific research, it can only be described as being proposed with an abundance of caution. There is no reason to suspect a problem, but the world has changed since 1996 and another look can’t hurt. After all, not only is mobile technology vastly more common, but it’s changing. Things like directional antennas may warrant some changes to the ways the FCC tests that devices meet emissions requirements.

Coping mechanisms

If you’re concerned about RF energy emitted by a mobile phone, here are a few things you can do:
  • Limit call time. Just don’t talk as much. Consider using text messages or other messaging services for things that don’t require direct interaction.
  • Use a headset or speakerphone. Although wired headsets can conduct a bit of energy to your head and Bluetooth headsets are themselves RF emitters, the levels are far lower than those emitted from mobile phones.
  • Keep your phone a little further away. Folks who carry a cell phone around in a pants pocket may not be pressing it to their head, but they’re pressing it to another part of their body. Consider keeping your phone in a bag or jacket pocket that keeps the device farther away from you.
Cancer cell image via Shutterstock / Robert J. Daveant
Cell tower image via Shutterstock / noolwlee]
Microwave hazard via Shutterstock / XAOC
Children and smartphone via Shutterstock / photo video the same object

http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/should-the-fcc-look-for-mobile-phone-cancer-link/

Girl battles rare brain tumor


Girl battles rare brain tumor

Only 7 in world have been diagnosed

5:14 PM, Jun 19, 2012

MANITOWOC — A 14-month-old sweet-faced, easy-going Manitowoc girl is battling a rare brain tumor.
Ireland Gorman was diagnosed in March with pineal anlage brain tumor, only the seventh patient in the world believed to have received this diagnosis, said her mother, Corinne Gorman, during a phone interview from Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin in Milwaukee.
The sixth case reported in English-language literature, that of a 5-month-old boy, was detailed in the June 2010 Journal of Neurosurgury: Pediatrics. The condition was first reported in a 9-year-old girl in 1989, said the article.
“It is likely that others have had the tumor and not been properly identified or reported. But there have only been six cases reported that we know of,” said Dr. Sean Lew, director of the neurosurgery epilepsy program at Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin.
Ireland’s tumor “was in the middle of her brain surrounded by vital structures and very large given her young age,” said Lew, who performed surgery to remove it.
Pineal anlage tumors may resemble other pineal tumors in the brain but are clearly distinct; how that affects treatment and overall prognosis is still uncertain, according to the Journal of Neurosurgury: Pediatrics.
What is certain is that the potentially deadly tumor has introduced Ireland to the world of surgery and chemotherapy at too early an age. It has turned her family’s life upside down.

Condition

Ireland’s condition came to light in late February, when she began vomiting and seemed lethargic, Corinne said.
The first trip to the emergency room didn’t turn up anything, but a few days later, Ireland was unable to look at her mother.
“I called her pediatrician. I was crying and said she can’t even make eye contact with me. He told me to take her to the emergency room. When I brought her in, she was seizuring. They did a CT scan and she had a large mass in her brain, they told me. It wound up being about the size of my fist,” Corinne said.
“We were hit by truck,” she said of the news. “We were absolutely stunned when we were in the emergency room and they told us she had a brain tumor. My husband absolutely lost it.”

Doubts cast over consumer benefits of smart meters

Doubts cast over consumer benefits of smart meters




SPECIAL REPORT / The European Commission has asked member states to present before September their cost-benefit analyses on the deployment of smart meters that could lead to 80% of consumers being equipped with intelligent metering systems by 2020. But a recent study casts doubts over their cost-effectiveness and the benefits they bring to consumers.
Smart meters record energy or water consumption, sending the readings back to the power or water suppliers for monitoring and billing. A cost-benefit analysis currently deployed in member states will be finalised by 3 September 2012.
In a recommendation paper, the European Commission says it is yet to be convinced that smarts meters are “economically justified”.
The EU executive's doubts are being raised despite an increased acceptance of smart meters across European countries. In Italy and Sweden, smart meters cover almost 100% of households while they have been rolled-out on a large scale in the UK and Spain.
Consumers 'underrepresented'
However, a recently published study of the Free University in Brussels (ULB) commissed by the European Consumers Organisation BEUC,  found that consumers are not the main beneficiaries of this technology, calling current efforts “a missed opportunity” for end-users.
“Smart meters might be beneficial to some consumers, but we certainly have doubts about whether they will be beneficial to all consumers,” Johannes Kleis of BEUC told EurActiv.
Smart meter are controlled by producers and sellers while consumers are underrepresented and “energy savings” is not a main objective, BEUC’s study says. It also says many energy users are not yet educated about how to benefit from smart meters.
But giant industry players are already one step ahead of the game, having pioneered different smart meter scenarios for users and energy retailers. Bastian Fischer of Oracle says technology means consumers have gone from being “victims” of meters to being more actively involved in their energy consumption and billing.
“From victims of the meters we are becoming active members of the supply chain and can influence what energy we can consume – the same goes for shirting the energy load and choosing our own energy mix,” Fischer told a recent conference on smart metering.
Policy is crucial in providing the right incentives for investors, Fischer agreed. “We need to marry business policy and technology to make it easier for consumers to adapt,” he said.
Conflicting savings estimates
Several national assessments of the impact of smart meters have so far showed conflicting savings predictions, which range from 2% to 40%.
Only around 10 % of EU households have some sort of smart meter installed, according to the European Commission, and these users have reduced their energy consumption by 10% or even more in some cases.
In Britain, the AlertMe project allows customers to turn off appliances by web interface or mobile; in eight months, residents have saved roughly 40 % electricity. In Spain, the forecasts by the GAD project show that a normal consumer could save 15% of total energy consumption, European Commission figures show.
The Dutch government has estimated that smart meters can conserve up to 10% of all energy used in a household.
But ULB researchers analysed six energy industry studies on the use of smart meters showing savings of between 2-4% in the best cases where consumers opted for their use. The six studies were undertaken by EDF (France), E.ON (Germany), Scottish Power, SSE (Scottish and Southern Energy), CER (Commission for Energy Regulation in Ireland) and Intelliekon (Germany).
Who benefits?
Consumers representatives worry that producers and energy suppliers “could be the ones taking all the benefits” from the EU-wide deployment of smart-metering systems.
If demand-response becomes compulsory there will be some low-income consumers who are already using very little energy for very basic activities and will not be able to reduce their consumption any further, Monika Stajnarova, an expert on smart meters for BEUC told EurActiv.
“We are against the mandatory roll out [of smart meters] for the whole population - some consumers will pay for the smart meter all the while not being  able to benefit from them. Consumers need to be given the choice,” Stajnarova said.
The BEUC report shows that the possible hypotheses the Commission has used to draw its conclusion on the consumers' need for smart meters is “too general with regards to the plurality of consumers, and the huge diversity of practices involved in households”. To present, there is no study that considers the diversity of consumers when assessing the energy savings potential, the report found.
However, the consulting firm Frontier Economics has developed a model based on 200 different types of households in order to assess for which consumers smart meters would be financially beneficial. In one case, just 15% of surveyed households in Germany benefited from the country’s compulsory roll-out of smart meters.
Who pays?
“Energy suppliers will, of course, try to push any cost they have on final customers,” Gierulski of the Commission's energy efficiency unit said at a recent smart-metering workshop.
“Companies need to be sure they will make a profit in order to invest,” said Gunnar Lorenz of Eurelectric. “We have to explain to customers what this box is and what it does so that they trust it and feel comfortable with it and do not feel like they are monitored by a big brother,” he added.
The European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) told EurActiv that it was worried about the fact the energy retailers will have access to energy consumption patters and will have a choice between being “generous” and helping the consumer to shift electricity loads and save money or not.
“The fact that a company knows a lot of personal information about us may make it easier to use this to its own advantage, which may mean, among other things, increasing the possibilities of price discrimination,” the EDPS said.
BEUC is critical about the socialisation of cost – in other words, power utilities spreading the costs implied by the roll-out of smart meters in 80% of households in an even manner amongst all of their clients. “There should be a  fair sharing of costs for all investments required, but also between all actors that could potentially benefit from the new meters: the different functionalities and benefits that they bring to different actors need to be analyzed and thus determine the distribution of costs amongst those actors,” Stajnarova said.
The Brattle Group consulting firm warned in 2009 about the major investments that the EU is poised to make in order to install smart meters in households EU-wide. They estimated that this would cost EU €51 billion by 2020, whilst the improvements would be between n €26 billion and 41 billion, leaving a gap of €10 billion to 25 billion between benefits and costs.
NEXT STEPS: 
  • 3 Sept. 2012: cost-benefit assessment shall take place by this date
  • end of 2012: the first deliverables for European standards for smart meters expected
  • by 2020: at least 80 % of consumers shall be equipped with intelligent meter­ing system, if cost-benefit analysis is positive