Monday, July 02, 2012

More on CTV’s supposedly independent reporting: Bell Canada bought 100 percent of CTV Inc. for $1.3 billion in 2010


More on CTV’s supposedly independent reporting: Bell Canada bought 100 percent of CTV Inc. for $1.3 billion in 2010

As a follow up to my blog of 28 June, titled “Canada TV caught out passing off industry spin as an investigative report”, it now turns out that CTV, Canada’s largest private broadcasting network, is 100% owned by Bell Canada (telecom).
Sent in by Susan Foster:

Investigative Something-ism: The Hazards of WiFi Radiation in Schools


SATURDAY, JUNE 30, 2012

Investigative Something-ism: The Hazards of WiFi Radiation in Schools

Without some semblance of intelligent public broadcasting, coverage like this (on any topic) can easily because the norm. There are a number of people who have a wealth of knowledge and who have concerns regarding both the content and representations in this CTV broadcast. It would seem that the email from Jon Woodward’s email address was sent out as, in effect, a form-letter reply to a high number of viewers who sent in their comments from all over Canada and the U.S. (and elsewhere?). (I didn’t write in, so I don’t have my own copy.) To follow the conversation, please start reading where I used red to mark the "Original Message."




Emailed June 30, 2012 to 
Jon.Woodward@bellmedia.ca

Jon,

I would like to add to what Iris has said.  She is absolutely correct that your investigative report was biased by virtue of the facts that you used "experts" known to be associated with  the telecommunications industry. You took the recommendation of sources at the University of British Columbia, a school that receives millions in donations from Bell, and ended up using Prof Dave Michelson who happens to be the past president of the IEEE - Vancouver Section.  The IEEE is filled with engineers who discount the non-thermal effects of RF (microwave) radiation, and make decisions about standard setting that far exceed what most European countries, Russia, and the US military consider even close to safe or protective. 

Doesn't it tell you something, Jon, that the University of British Columbia recommended Karl Reardon, formerly General Manager of Motorola’s Vancouver Research and Development Center and a significant force in raising allowable limits of exposure rather than an expert on the true biological effects of Wi-Fi on developing children? This conflict, which it is indeed, points out the difficulty we all have in getting to the truth of safety and health issues where giant corporations are involved. 

The vast majority of your viewing audience will take your report at face value, which is troubling because there is indeed risk associated with Wi-Fi exposure, especially to children.  It is not a question of if children are harmed, but how much and when will symptoms become manifest?  These risks are not going to be appropriately investigated unless you seek out truly independent sources and take measurements in the schools when no one is expecting you. I have been involved with cell towers on firestations, and if we announced ahead of time that we're taking measurements, we come out with ridiculously low readings. Measurements for cell towers are controlled from remote locations and can be turned up, or turned down.  I wonder who adjusted the Wi-Fi the day measurements were taken for your report? And as Iris asked, was the equipment used to test the Wi-Fi calibrated at an independent lab?  Somehow, I suspect not.

The reality is this: I'm not sure how you can achieve independence when your boss is Bell Canada.  I presume you know that Bell Canada bought 100 percent of CTV Inc. for $1.3 billion in 2010.  They previously owned only 15 percent; now they have full control of the company that you work for. They sign your paychecks.  Of course you are going to go where your immediate boss suggests, a university like almost all universities these days that enjoys the millions donated to them by Bell and/or other telecommunications giants.  That money pays for much needed programs, of course, and it buys something infinitely more valuable to the donors like Bell than the tax write-off and the pure pleasure of donating to higher education.  The telecom industry is buying influence, and so perhaps Iris Atzmon and I should be thanking you for pointing out this exquisite example of the far reaching tentacles of influence the telecommunications industry has.

You've been used, Jon, and we know it.  You were guided to a university that gave you a predictable recommendation.  What does it say to you that the University of British Columbia referred you to a professor who is the former chair of the Vancouver section of the IEEE, and a "consultant" who is without question an industry insider? That was not a true investigative report.  It is a whitewash and a broadcast to your viewers offering a false senses of security and safety.

Thank you for this magnificent example of industry influence that almost makes the tobacco industry look good.

Sincerely,

Susan Foster, MSW
Honorary Firefighter, San Diego Fire Dept
Co-Author, Res. 15 passed by the IAFF, 2004
Member, International EMF Alliance
Advisor, Radiation Research Trust, UK


From: Iris XX
Sent: Friday, June 29, 2012 2:35 AM
To: Jon Woodward
Subject: re: CTV Wi-Fi investigation

Jon,

Your email to me was adressed to yourself. I understand from other people that you sent the same reply to everyone.

To the point itself, I understand that the expert you relied on is Prof. Dave Michelson. He has conflicts of interests:

He is the chair of  Advisory Panel for Wavefront Wireless Commercialization Centre (WWCC). Industry partners include Sierra Wireless, Ericsson, Nokia, Orange and others. As a reporter, you are expected to bring a balanced report.

Are there different rules in your station? Why don't you do an honest declaration of conflict of interest before you come to calm down the public?  Where is the balance in your position?  Regarding the equipment itself, where was it calibrated?

do you have a certificate that it was calibrated in an independent lab?

You assume that people did not do homework before they express worries regarding WiFi. You are doing an underestimation here. Measurements were done independently from the industry and the results are conflicting with your programme.

But the most worrisome is this: what you actually tell me is that there are worries that Wi-Fi is dangerous and you adress them with a wireless industry person.  It's like saying that if you are worried about processed food and a reporter brings a Mcdonald's guy and he will tell you that it's just fine,  it's supposed to calm you down.  

Regards,

Iris



----- Original Message ----- 


From: 
Jon Woodward

To: 
Jon Woodward

Sent: Friday, June 29, 2012 11:16 PM

Subject: re: CTV Wi-Fi investigation




Hi,

Thanks for writing in. I apologize for taking a few days to write back to you but my duties as a daily reporter during those days kept me busy. I would rather take time to write a thoughtful response.

The point of the story was to put to the test concerns about wi-fi in schools. There are worries that wi-fi is dangerous, which we referred to in the report. We also reported the opinion that it is a safe and important learning tool. The scientific data concerned citizens use to support either side in this debate is often presented to the lay public without regard to the actual use of the technology in the schools in Vancouver at this time. The policy recommendation of the B.C. Confederation of Parent Advisory Councils was worth examining.

We came to the story with a question: what is happening at our schools, and how does this compare to exposure that children might face in other parts of their lives?

The Vancouver School Board gave us access to schools in the spirit of openness. We approached Karl Reardon, a consultant who came highly recommended from sources at the University of British Columbia and suppliers of the specialized testing equipment. We designed the experimental procedure and used high-tech equipment with standard protocols, while school was in session and while devices were used in a normal classroom or library setting. We saw for ourselves the readings on the devices. The readings were consistent during multiple tests. We explored the sources of signals in the schools with no wi-fi and traced some of them to everyday items like fluorescent lights. When we consulted experts in this technology at UBC, they told us our results were consistent with scientific expectations.

At no point was there any interference or input in our experimental procedures from any industry or outside source including our parent company, Bell.

Given the amount of debate over this issue to this point, it’s clear this story is hardly the last word. We did not test all Vancouver schools in all possible situations where wi-fi could be used, for example. We also made no conclusions about whether the wi-fi emissions themselves were safe. But I do hope that the story provided to parents who are concerned about this technology some context about the levels of wi-fi exposure that their children are facing at schools in Vancouver at this time.

Sincerely,
Jon Woodward

Jon Woodward | Investigative Reporter

CTV British Columbia |
750 Burrard Street Suite 300
Vancouver, BC V6Z 1X5

www.twitter.com/CTV_JonWoodward
http://www.ctvbc.ca

Study of WiFi health effects rejected


Study of WiFi health effects rejected

Oceanside Star

Published: Thursday, June 28, 2012
Trustees bickered Tuesday during debate on whether to look into the health effects of WiFi in schools.
Trustee Julie Austin proposed striking a district committee to research the health effects and role of WiFi in schools.
She was concerned about possible health effects of radio-frequency electromagnetic fields emitted from wireless technology.


It would not be an onerous task to strike a committee to research and report on this, she said, especially "when we are talking about our children's health." It would be "sad" to not look into the subject, she said.
Director of Instruction Gillian Wilson said WiFi has already been studied by the school district and information is available.
Austin called the available information "woefully lacking."
Wilson continued, asking Austin what the board would do if the committee, as she suspects, finds conflicting reports on whether or not WiFi is a health danger.
Vice-Chair Barry Kurland said it's not in the school board's realm to make a decision for every school in the district. He suggest Parent Advisory Councils could handle the situation.
Austin replied that PACs are already too busy, to which Kurland responded that perhaps that shows WiFi is not a high priority for research.
"It's all about information, Barry," replied Austin, before Chair Lynette Kershaw ended the discussion and called a vote.
Her proposal was defeated.

Where is EWG's cell phone database?


Where is EWG's cell phone database?

The Environmental Working Group has decided to suspend its publication of Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) values of cell phones in light of rapidly transforming mobile technology and the cloak of secrecy around it.
When EWG published its ground-breaking 2009 report on cell phone radiation, publicly available data supported our view that a government-mandated measurement called the Specific Absorption Rate for individual phones was an important factor that influenced the user's radiation exposure. This finding was based on multiple studies conducted around the world – and multiple national health services that advised consumers to buy low SAR phones, even though experts recognized that SAR values are just one of the factors determining radiation exposure.
As EWG pointed out, in 1996 the cell phone industry persuaded the Federal Communications Commission that for local exposure, such as at the head, people could safely absorb up to 1.6 watts per kilogram (W/kg) of body weight of cell phone radiation. The FCC's decision was based on short-term exposures, usually less than an hour in duration. Moreover, the FCC's method for measuring SAR allowed 20 times more radiation to reach the head than the body as a whole and did not account for risks to children's smaller bodies.
In those days, people didn't spend much time on mobile phones, because the devices were pricey, airtime was exorbitant and texting was virtually unknown. Few people were thinking about the potential long-term impacts of children's cell phone use when a new phone cost $2,000. Times have changed. But the FCC's regulations have not. They have never been updated to reflect the new reality of frequent daily cell phone use that for most people would last for decades and cell phone use by children and teenagers.
In addition to SAR, other factors that could affect the intensity and duration of emissions to which a person is exposed include frequency at which the phone operates, connection strength and distance between cell phone and the user's body. Yet FCC does not require cell phone manufacturers to conduct real-life SAR measurements and to disclose this information. Consequently, cell phone users and independent researchers do not have reliable information about cell phone radiation under specific conditions of use.
Industry research that has belatedly become public has shown that a consumer using the same phone on two different 2G (second generation) network technologies – GSM (Global System for Mobile Communication) vs. CDMA (Code Division Multiple Access) – could be subjected to radiation levels differing by a factor of 30 or even 300 (Kelsh 2011). This study, conducted by the cell phone industry in 2005 and 2006 but released only in 2010, demonstrated that network differences were the key factor determining the user's exposure to cell phone radiation.
CDMA-based technologies, including the original CDMA and its variations such as UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunication System, 3G technology in mobile telecommunications) result in much lower user exposure to radiation (Georg 2006; Kühn 2009; Swiss Federal Office of Public Health 2011). In contrast, GSM, historically the world's most common 2G technology, is a higher-radiation technology (Ardoino 2004). According to studies that specifically focused on GSM, phones using this technology can emit the highest level of radiation during nearly half of the call time. In a multi-national study that involved more than 500 volunteers and 60,000 calls using GSM network technology, the average output power was 50 percent of the phones' maximum power level and ranged from 35 to 70 percent, depending on the country (Vrijheid 2009).
Yet despite these provocative finding, neither the industry nor other institutions followed up with published research on radiation levels in the next-generation network protocols that industry describes with a catchy title of Long Term Evolution, or LTE.
Cell phone makers are caught up in a race to produce faster, more powerful mobile devices – and no one is asking hard questions about the unintended consequences for human health of seemingly limitless growth of the wireless industry.
We are.
In the face of multiplying uncertainties, with virtually no data on network-dependent radiation levels, EWG has decided not to continue publishing its cell phone radiation guide. EWG intends this action as a statement of protest at the absence of authoritative, credible data that could help consumers make informed choices about the mobile communications devices they bring into their homes, schools and workplaces.
What can you do to help make full disclosure a reality? Click here to take action.
References
Ardoino L, Barbieri E, Vecchia P. 2004. Determinants of exposure to electromagnetic fields from mobile phones. Radiat Prot Dosimetry 111(4): 403-6.
Georg R. 2006. Bestimmung der spezifischen Absorptionsrate (SAR-Werte), die während der alltäglichen Nutzung von Handys auftritt [Determination of SAR-values occurring during the everyday use of mobile phones]. In German. Available:http://www.emf-forschungsprogramm.de/forschung/dosimetrie/dosimetrie_abges/dosi_050.html
International Telecommunications Union. 2011. The World in 2011. Information and Communication Technologies Facts and Figures. Available: http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/ict/facts/2011/index.html
Kelsh MA, Shum M, Sheppard AR, McNeely M, Kuster N, Lau E, et al. 2011. Measured radiofrequency exposure during various mobile-phone use scenarios. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 21: 343-54.
Kühn S. 2009. EMF risk assessment. exposure assessment and compliance testing in complex environments. Doctoral Thesis. Swiss Federal Institue of Technology (ETH). Available: http://e-collection.ethbib.ethz.ch/view/eth:1115
Swiss Federal Office of Public Health. 2011. Mobile phones. Available:http://www.bag.admin.ch/themen/strahlung/00053/00673/04265/index.html?lang=en
Vrijheid M, Mann S, Vecchia P, Wiart J, Taki M, Ardoino L, et al. 2009. Determinants of mobile phone output power in a multinational study - implications for exposure assessment. Occup Environ Med 66(10): 664-71.
WHO (World Health Organization). 2011. IARC Classified Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields as Possibly Carcinogenic to Humans. Press Release # 208. 31 May 2011. Available: http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2011/pdfs/pr208_E.pdf

Mobile radiation scare in Jaipur

Mobile radiation scare in Jaipur


Rajasthan says levels within permissible limit. Critics claim even ‘safe’ levels are harmful
imagePhoto: Ankur PaliwalSUDHIR KASLIWAL has been living in a Jaipur colony with his family since the 1970s. A jeweller by profession, his life was going smooth until last year when one of his two brothers was diagnosed with brain tumour. He was rushed to Mumbai for treatment. Then his other brother was also detected with brain tumour. “His doctor enquired about our surroundings. When we told him there are three cell phone towers within 20 metres of our house, he cautioned us,” says Kasliwal. Around the same time, his dog fell victim to cancer.
In another colony of Jaipur was Hameeda Patel who succumbed to cervical cancer last month. The 53-year-old used to live with her family in a one-room flat on the first floor. The room is 50 metres away from a building that has a cell phone tower and four antennas. “She was the first cancer patient in our family,” says her son. Since 2010, five persons have died of cancer and five are battling the disease in Patel’s colony that has about 15 cell phone towers.
These are some instances of the health scare that has engulfed Rajasthan’s capital. Although there is no conclusive evidence to prove that electromagnetic radiations (EMR) emitted by antennas on cell phone towers are causing cancer, there could be a link. All the cancer patients in the areas Down To Earth visited were the first in their generation to suffer from the disease and were diagnosed after towers were erected in their vicinity.
The increasing number of cancer cases has people worried. On February 24, two people filed a petition in the Rajasthan High Court. They urged the court to take action against cell phone service providers and the regulatory authorities. On May 31, the court formed a committee to monitor EMR in the city for a month and submit report with suggestions (for more, see "Mobile tower risks: Rajasthan High Court issues notice to telecom operators").
To further address public concerns, the state government organised a workshop on June 2, which was attended by technical and medical experts. “The cancer cases are a mere coincidence. There are multiple causes of cancer like pollution and lifestyle changes,” says Rajesh Pasricha, senior consultant, department of radiotherapy, Bhagwan Mahaveer Cancer Hospital and Research Centre, Jaipur. There is no conclusive evidence to show that EMR is responsible for cancer, he adds.
Officials from the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) say the radiation levels in Jaipur are below the permissible limit. Mahidhar Pant, deputy director general, Telecom Enforcement Resource and Monitoring (TERM) cell, Jaipur, says, “We are required to randomly monitor EMR of 10 per cent of the 5,678 towers in the city annually. We have never found EMR beyond the permissible limit.” But there is no independent verification of the TERM readings, points out Prakash Munshi, an anti-radiation activist in Mumbai.
When less is bad
Even at permissible level, EMR could hurt people. After doctor’s caution, Kasliwal had his house tested for EMR. “The levels were high in the rooms occupied by his brothers, but were within permissible limits,” says Girish Kumar, professor in the electrical engineering department at IIT-Bombay, who measured the radiation.
Precautions taken
 
Although there is no conclusive proof that electromagnetic radiations (EMR) from cell phone towers affect health, many countries have taken precautionary steps. In Italy the permissible EMR is 1 Watt per m2, but in sensitive areas like residential areas, schools and hospitals it is 0.1 Watt per m2. Similar is the case in Switzerland where the countrywide limit is 4.5 Watt per m2 while in sensitive areas it is 0.042 Watt per m2. Nations like Russia, Bulgaria and Poland are playing it safer. They have restricted the limit to 0.1 Watt per m2
 
How can radiation level within the permissible limit be harmful? India follows the norms of International Commission on Non Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP), Kumar says. It is an independent scientific body that provides guidance on the health hazards of non-ionising radiation exposure.
V K Vijay, director of the Centre for Development of Physics and Education in the University of Rajasthan, sheds more light. “EMR are non-ionising radiations. They have electrical and magnetic field, but no charge. On contact, the field affects the normal dynamics of the human body. But the exact effect is not known,” he says.
According to ICNIRP, the permissible limit for exposure is 4.5 Watt per m2. The reading in Kasliwal’s house was about 0.005 Watt per m2. “Consistent exposure of even 0.001 Watt per m2 is harmful,” says Kumar. Besides cancer, such exposure can damage DNA. “People complain of problems like sleep disorders and hypertension,” he adds. He cites a study conducted in Germany from 1994 to 2004 which found a threefold increase in cancer risk after five years’ exposure to radiations from a cell phone tower at a distance of 400 metres. “At this range, the radiation would be 0.00008 Watt per m2,” says Kumar.
In countries which follow ICNIRP like Russia, Italy and Poland, the permissible limits are 0.1, 1 and 0.1 Watt per m2, respectively (see ‘Precautions taken’). Kumar says the ICNIRP guidelines are intended to protect people from the short-term heating effects and not from biological effects of long-term low-level exposure from towers.
imageJaipur has 5,678 cell phone towers
An expert group commissioned by the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests last year to study the countrywide impact of EMR on birds found the exposure was reducing the number of birds and hurting bees’ egg production. “If birds are getting affected by the radiations, then humans can also be at risk,” says Kumar. Many international studies also show harmful effects of EMR on health. For example, a study conducted between 1996 and 2006 in a Brazil municipality showed that mortality rate due to neoplasia (abnormal cell growth) was higher for people within an area of 500-metre from cell phone base stations.
However WHO, which reviewed 1,000 studies on the health effects of EMR, says there is no convincing scientific evidence to confirm that low radiation from cell phone towers affects health. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies EMR as a possible carcinogen because of limited proof. No convincing evidence does not mean no evidence, says Kumar. “We agree that it is a matter of research. But till then should we keep getting ourselves exposed to harmful EMR?” asks Kasliwal.
Last year, an inter-ministerial committee formed by DoT on EMR had recommended reducing the permissible limit by one tenth (0.45 Watt per m2). It is supposed to be implemented by September. But Cellular Operators Association of India says the recommendation has no scientific basis.
Lack of regulation
An official of the state Urban Development and Housing (UDH) department says initially there was no restriction on the number of cell phone towers to ensure best connectivity to people. As a result, discoms set up towers indiscriminately. “Even we do not know of their possible harmful effects,” he says. But for the sake of regulation, the government made model cell phone tower bylaws in 2010. These bylaws with a few modifications were made mandatory in September last year.
Besides TERM, Jaipur Municipal Corporation is also supposed to monitor towers every month, but it hardly does. The country has no official guidelines on the height of tower, distance between towers and distance from houses. “The towers are put based on radio-planning where we take care of all these issues,” says Pant of TERM. G S Sandhu, principal secretary, UDH, says, “We are looking into the matter and would soon release guidelines.”

Hundreds concerned over smart meters


Hundreds concerned over smart meters

Many consumers want to opt out of smart meters

Updated: Friday, 29 Jun 2012, 11:01 PM EDT
Published : Friday, 29 Jun 2012, 11:01 PM EDT
MICHIGAN (WOOD) - Nearly 400 customers are speaking up about smart meters, including some who said they want to be able to opt out of the metering system. 

The "Smart Meter Report" was released Friday by the Michigan Public Service Commission and outlined several concerns by the public including the cost, benefits, safety of the radio transmitter, and customer privacy. 

But the majority of those commenting expressed concerns regarding the actual installation of smart meter technology. 

The new smart meters automatically report usage six times a day to Consumer's Energy and can allow the company to control power to customers. 

According to the report, traditional electromechanical meters are obsolete and are no longer being produced. 

The MPSC says any risks are insignificant. If a consumer wants to opt out, the commission recommends charging a fee, and a reduced rate for those who use the smart meter. 

Consumer's Energy estimates it will cost around $750 million for meter installation, along with other system upgrades and expenses. 

A graph in the commission's report shows 84 percent of the customers who commented expressed concerns about being able to opt out or deny installation. That same graph shows 77 percent expressed concerns regarding health issues and privacy. 
  
To read the entire "Smart Grid Report", click here .

Friday, June 29, 2012

Nuclear Shutdown

Nuclear Shutdown


  • Please forward widely to your political representatives
  • Please circulate widely and repost, but you must give the URL of the original and preserve all the links back to articles on our website. If you find this report useful, please support ISIS by subscribing to our magazineScience in Society, and encourage your friends to do so. Or have a look at the ISIS bookstore for other publications

Now or never


  • “We lost Japan,” said Rie Inomata, who works as an interpreter [1].
  • “I feel guilty and sorry for the children. They did not choose nuclear power plants, they did not choose to be born; but it is them that have to suffer in the future.”
  • “By not protesting against nuclear power I allowed this accident to happen. If we go in the same direction, I don’t see any future.”
  • “If we [are to] make a difference, we must decide now, it is now or never.”

Potential future of Fukushima children written in Chernobyl

The potential future for the Fukushima children victims is written starkly in the government birth and death registries of the heavily contaminated regions in the Chernobyl fallout; dedicated doctors, scientists, and ordinary citizens are bearing witness to the humanitarian disaster still unfolding.

There have been at least close to a million excess deaths, with general mortality rates doubled or tripled [2] (Chernobyl Deaths Top a Million Based on Real Evidence, SiS 55). A diversity of illnesses continue to claim lives including those of children: birth abnormalities, cancers, cardiovascular malfunction, premature aging, defects affecting practically every organ system, often multiple illnesses in the same individual, all associated with exposure to radioactivity in the body either inhaled or ingested in contaminated food. The number of children in Belarus has fallen by more than 27% since 2000, despite increasing birth rates. The horrific health impacts of the nuclear accident are still emerging more than 26 years later because the land is still contaminated, and the genetic/epigenetic legacy is just as long lasting.

Many of the deaths and sicknesses could have been avoided had governments not done their best to suppress the evidence from the start, even to the point of persecuting doctors and scientists - who put their lives and careers at risk in trying to save the children -including cutting off major funding for a simple treatment that would have reduced the children’s radioactive burden [3, 4] (Apple Pectin for Radioprotection, The Pectin Controversy, SiS 55).

Fukushima fallout as big as Chernobyl

Chernobyl was generally recognized as the biggest nuclear accident in history. Within days of the first explosion, Fukushima was reclassified by the International Atomic Energy Agency to the highest grade 7 – with “widespread health and environmental effects” – the same as Chernobyl [5] (Fukushima Nuclear Crisis, SiS 50).

But as in Chernobyl, the government has withheld vital information from people, the international regulators are downplaying the health impacts, and to this day, the total radioactivity released from the stricken Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant is still unknown [6] (Truth about Fukushima, SiS 55).

The most authoritative estimates based on measurements carried out by the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty monitoring stations around the globe indicate that the total radioactivity released from the Fukushima accident is at least as great as from Chernobyl; some 15 times the official estimate, and much more global in reach [7] (Fukushima Fallout Rivals Chernobyl, SiS 55). The radioactivity in the waste water discharged into the Pacific Ocean is already the single largest release into the ocean in history.

The Japanese government’s own measurements show widespread contamination, with levels of radioactivity outside the official evacuation zone so high that within a matter of weeks, people would have been exposed to 10-200 times the legal limit dose for a whole year [6]. Evacuation especially of children from those areas is a matter of the utmost urgency. Yet the Japanese government is still refusing to do that.  

Nuclear reactors to restart despite lag in crisis plan

On 16 June 2o12, Japanese premier Noda ordered the restart of two nuclear reactors amid widespread protest, and new crisis plans drafted after the Fukushima disaster are still to be implemented by any local community living near the nuclear power reactors. The Ohi nuclear reactors to be restarted are a case in point.

If a Fukushima-style meltdown were to happen, the only route for escape or sending help is [8] “a winding, cliff-hugging road often closed by snow in winter or clogged by beachgoers in summer.” Radioactivity from the meltdown could contaminate Lake Biwa, the country’s biggest freshwater source serving 14 million people. The reactors sit on Wakasa Bay, a region home to 13 commercial reactors. Some of the crucial measures designed to protect residents in the new crisis plans are not ready, such as a raised seawall in 2013 and an onsite command centre by March 2o16. And filter vents that could reduce radiation leaks to the environment won’t be ready for three more years.

The Fukui provincial government has only started survey in June 2012 for a multibillion dollar project to repair the sole route to the Ohi nuclear plant and to add a new alternative evacuation road.

Governor Yukuko Kada of neighbouring Shiga province accuses the central government of still ignoring the residents, and says it has still refused to provide radiation simulation data she has asked for in order to compile an evacuation map and to study the impact on Lake Biwa, as another Fukushima-class crisis could “instantly make the lake water undrinkable.”
Public opposition to resuming operations remains high because of the Fukushima disaster and a lingering distrust of the nuclear industry as well as the pro-nuclear regulators and governments.

But the public have good reason on their side.

Big nuclear accidents 200 times more often than previous estimates

Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Chemistry in Mainz have calculated that catastrophic nuclear accidents such as Chernobyl and Fukushima may occur once every 10 to 20 years, based on the operating hours of all civil nuclear reactors and the number of nuclear meltdowns that have occurred [9]. This is more than 200 times as often than estimated in the past. The research team also determined that in the event of such a major accident, half of the long-lived radioactive caesium-137 would be spread over an area extending more than 1 000 km away from the reactor. Western Europe in particular is likely to be contaminated about once in 50 years by more than 40kBq of Cs-137 per square metre, a level upwards that the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) defines as ‘contaminated’.

Their calculations showed that if a single nuclear meltdown were to occur in Western Europe, ~ 28 million people would be affected by contamination of more than 40 kBq per square metre.  In southern Asia, the dense population would put the number of people affected by a major nuclear accident at ~34 million, while in the eastern USA and in East Asia this would be 14 to 21 million.

Fukushima has triggered Germany’s exit from their nuclear power programme. It is to close down all 17 nuclear reactors and replace them with renewable energies, mostly wind and solar, and has invested €200 billion (8 % of the country’s GDP) towards that end [10]. “Germany's exit from the nuclear energy program will reduce the national risk of radioactive contamination.” said Director and lead author of the Max Planck study Jos Lelieveld, an atmosphere chemist [9]. “However, an even stronger reduction would result if Germany’s neighbours were to switch off their reactors. Not only do we need an in-depth and public analysis of the actual risks of nuclear accidents. In light of our findings I believe an internationally coordinated phasing out of nuclear energy should also be considered.”

Some governments have too cosy a relationship with the nuclear industry

The UK government is chief among those countries with nuclear ambitions undaunted by the Fukushima disaster. It is still determined to go ahead with the construction of at least 10 new reactors, despite plenty of counter-evidence available to it, which include evidence that an adequate supply of low carbon energy could be produced without it, to the point of misleading Parliament by omission of the evidence in order to get the decision through [11] (UK’s Nuclear Illusion, SiS 55), and with a huge public subsidy. Why?
The most likely explanation is a too-cosy relationship between the government and the nuclear industry, which applies in other countries like France [12] (The True Costs of French Nuclear Power , SiS 53) with close links to nuclear weaponry. But times have changed, the nuclear option is a dinosaur, both as far as energy supply and defence is concerned, and it is time to end the nuclear illusion once and for all.

WHO cannot be trusted

The World Health Organisation (WHO), which should have been an independent regulator of nuclear safety, has long abandoned this obligation. In 1959, the WHO signed an agreement (WHA 12-40) with IAEA that effectively gave the IAEA responsibility for health issues arising from the civilian use of nuclear power. The terms of the agreement are freely available to the public [13] but they are still not widely known, with the result that most people are unaware that reports and other documents that purport to have major input from the WHO, the agency set up by the UN in 1948 to deal with international health issues, are actually from the IAEA, the body whose mission is to promote the nuclear industry. The WHO has put its name on documents such as the 2003-2005 report of the Chernobyl Forum [14] that it had little to do with; it could not have because it has no department for nuclear health and no experts in the field. Its report on Fukushima, similarly, cannot be trusted [15] (WHO Report on Fukushima a Travesty, SiS 55)
IndependentWHO, an organisation concerned about the dangers of nuclear power in general and the consequences of Chernobyl and Fukushima in particular, demands the revision of agreement WHA 12/40, and has held a vigil outside WHO headquarters in Geneva every working day since April 2007 to draw attention to the crime of non-assistance to the victims of Chernobyl and now Fukushima. (For more, see its web site:http://independentwho.org/en/.)

Thanks to the IndependentWHO, the editors of SiS were invited to the Scientific and Citizen Forum on Radioprotection – From Chernobyl to Fukushima, 11-13 May 2012, Geneva, which the group organized. This led to the series of articles that has been collected into the present report, Death Camp Fukushima Chernobyl.

Special report to be included in Science in Society #55 (available August 2012).Pre-order now or Subscribe. All proceeds from SiS 55 will be donated to children of Fukushima and Chernobyl
Death Camp Fukushima Chernobyl

Death Camp Fukushima Chernobyl is a concise summary of scientific evidence on:
  • The devastating health consequences of the Chernobyl radioactivity fallout suppressed by governments and pro-nuclear regulatory authorities
  • The real extent of the Fukushima fallout and health hazards faced by victims, both downplayed by the Japanese government and the regulatory authorities
  • New findings on the amplified health impacts of low dose ionizing radiation
  • Simple radioprotection measures.
It also shows why the official picture presented by organisations such as the WHO is highly misleading, and why countries still determined to go nuclear are clinging to obsolete energy and defence policies.

The report makes clear that children living in the highly contaminated areas outside the official evacuation zone around Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear plants must be evacuated promptly in order to avert a humanitarian disaster on the scale of Chernobyl.  Concerted international effort is needed to provide help for evacuating the children and to continue health monitoring and research on radioprotection. Finally, a global phase out of nuclear power is in order given that a combination of renewable energy options can provide all our energy needs safely, sustainably and at much more affordable costs for all, as we made the case thoroughly in ([16] Green Energies - 100% Renewable by 2050, ISIS Report). 

References

  1. Stories from Fukushima, Message in a Bottle, From the kids of Fukushima to the World, accessed 20 June 2012,http://message.in.a.bottle.over-blog.com/pages/STORIES_FROM_FUKUSHIMA_ENGLISH-6985709.html
  2. Ho MW. Chernobyl deaths top a million. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  3. Ho MW. Apple pectin for radioprotection. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  4. Greaves S. The pectin controversy. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  5. Ho MW. Fukushima nuclear crisis. Science in Society 50m 4-9, 2011.
  6. Ho MW. Truth about Fukushima. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  7. Ho MW. Fukushima fallout rivals Chernobyl. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  8. “Crisis plans lag even as Japan’s reactors restart”, Mari Yamaguchi, Associated Press, chron.com,  21 June 2012, http://www.chron.com/business/article/Crisis-plans-lag-even-as-Japan-s-reactors-restart-3650896.php#page-1
  9. “Probability of contamination from nuclear accidents is higher than expected” Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, 22 May 2012, http://www.mpg.de/5809418/reactor_accidents
  10. “Germany swaps nuclear for solar and wind power”, Oliver Lazenby, Truthout, 22 June 2012, http://truth-out.org/news/item/9932-germany-swaps-nuclear-for-solar-and-wind-power
  11. Saunders PT. UK’s nuclear illusion. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  12. Greaves S . The true costs of French nuclear power. Science in Society 53, 8-11, 2012.
  13. Agreement between the International Atomic Energy Agency and the  World Health Organisation, IAEA/WHO, 1959, http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Documents/Infcircs/Others/inf20.shtml#note_c
  14. Chernobyl’s Legacy: Health Environmental and Socio-Economic Impacts and Recommendations to the Governments of Belarus, the Russian Federation and Ukraine. IAEA Division of Public Information. Vienna, IAEA, 2006, http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Booklets/Chernobyl/chernobyl.pdf
  15. Greaves S. WHO report on Fukushima a travesty. Science in Society 55 (to appear) 2012.
  16. Ho MW, Brett C, Burcher S and Saunders PT. Green Energies, 100 % Renewables by 2050, ISIS/TWN, London/Penang, 2009, http://www.i-sis.org.uk/GreenEnergies.php