PG&E to Pay $1B for CA Wildfires. But What About Lawsuits for Smart Meter Fires? Is There A Link?

By B.N. Frank

It only takes a spark to get a fire going…

If you hadn’t heard, Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) has finally agreed to pay $1B in damages for starting several California wildfires.

From NBCNews:

A California utility blamed for igniting several wildfires caused by downed power lines that killed dozens and destroyed thousands of homes agreed Tuesday to pay $1 billion in damages to local governments.

Attorneys representing 14 local public entities announced the settlement with Pacific Gas & Electric to cover “taxpayer losses.”

But will we ever know for sure whether or not PG&E Utility Smart Meter fires and explosions played any role in those wildfires?  In the past, PG&E customers had filed lawsuits claiming that the company’s “Smart” Meters had caught fire on their homes.  Insurance companies had also taken their side.  After all, in 2015 hundreds of PG&E smart meters simultaneously exploded after a truck caused a power surge in Stockton, CA.

Even if you don’t have Smart Meters from PG&E – there is plenty of documentation that other utility companies’ Smart Meters have caught fire and exploded too.  In fact, hundreds of thousands of Smart Meters have been recalled or replaced throughout North America due to fires and explosions:

• Remote disconnect switch failure resulted in a recall of over 10,000 Smart Meters in Lakeland, Florida where 6 house fires occurred.
• More Fires, More Smart Meter Recalls for Sensus:  Utilities pull 105,000meters in Canada, 70,000 in Oregon; Sensus says it’s not at fault.
• PECO halts Smart Meter Installation After Meter Overheating.
• Reno, Sparks fire chiefs to call for Smart Meter Probe.
• Power surge raises questions about Smart Meters. East Palo Alto electricity surge burnt out digital meters.
• Surge Blows Smart Meters Leaves Neighbourhood Without Hydro
• Thousands of Smart Meter Fires: New Whistleblower and Court Evidence
• BCUC & Smart Meter Fires: The Failure to Protect (See pages 27-30 for statements from engineers)

In 2018, Duke Energy also admitted that some of their AMI Smart Meters had caught fire.

Utility Smart Meters are problematic in other ways other than fires and explosions.

Source

California power company caused wildfire that killed 85, investigation finds

The Camp fire, the deadliest blaze in California history, almost completely incinerated the town of Paradise

A major power company is responsible for the deadliest wildfire in California history, an investigation by the state fire agency Cal Fire has found.

The Camp fire, which killed 85 people and almost completely incinerated the town of Paradise, was sparked by transmission lines owned by Pacific Gas & Electric in the early morning of 8 November last year, investigators concluded. “Tinder dry vegetation” and high winds “caused extreme rates of spread”, Cal Fire said in a statement.

“It brings some finality,” the Paradise mayor, Jody Jones, told the Guardian about Cal Fire’s conclusions.

'Paradise was sent to hell': revisiting the town destroyed by wildfire

 

Read more

PG&E filed for bankruptcy in January, facing billions of dollars in liabilities over multiple disasters in the state, and admitted at the time that its lines were the likely source of the Camp fire.

The company supplies power to large swathes of northern California, and runs power lines connected to hydroelectric power generators in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada mountains. A tower on one of those lines, constructed in the 1920s in the north fork of the Feather River canyon and well past its projected lifespan, is implicated in the Camp fire.

Pinterest

At about 6.15am on 8 November, there was an outage on the line, and PG&E employees and contractors reported seeing a patch of flames below it. Within a matter of hours, the flames had leaped from the canyon and raced several miles to the towns of Paradise and Magalia.

PG&E infrastructure had earlier been fingered for the Butte fire in 2015, which left two people dead,and a 2010 pipeline explosion in the town of San Bruno that killed eight people.

Critics say that because PG&E is an investor-owned company, it is incentivized to direct profits to shareholders rather than to safety measures. PG&E counters that its customers’ wellbeing is its top priority.

Yet investigators have consistently found cause for concern, and a 2013 report to the California public utilities commission stated that “several aspects of the PG&E distribution system present significant safety issues”.

In Paradise, the pace of rebuilding is slow. According to the mayor, news about the fire’s ignition will seem secondary to immediate, more material concerns.

“I haven’t heard anybody talk about that in months,” Jones said. “People are more focused on rebuilding, getting their lots cleared, getting their building permit, finding a place to live in the meantime.”

But, Jones added, she was hopeful the findings may be helpful in negotiations over the town’s lawsuit against PG&E. And it may spur progress in many of the other lawsuits filed by Paradisians who lost relatives or homes.